Grief Mythology: Mourning Can Create Alternate Realities

139610717It is not unusual for someone who experiences a loss to romanticize the person, identity, or object they are grieving. This can occur even when what is lost was not just imperfect, but harmful. This tendency occurs more often and can be more harmful with folks who experienced depression, anxiety, or other mental health issues prior to the loss.

Myths can be helpful in meeting the obligation of respect and mourning we may feel toward the person. They can push us to broaden our memory of the person who died or the relationship we had beyond just the negative event to more positive or helpful content. They can influence the “story” of what was lost in a way that makes thoughts and emotions associated with the loss more tolerable to access and communicate individually and within our support systems.

It is natural to go back in time and reevaluate our perceptions of events and the decisions made during that time. Those who struggle with depression or anxiety already have a distorted view of reality that usually presents a world that’s unsafe or themselves as incapable. Both of these factors can set the stage for harmful myths.

Beliefs that drive guilt, regret, and failure are usually present and, when applied to the loss of a relationship, can set the stage for a rewrite on reality. These factors can result in a person deriving a meaning or value from what was lost that is heightened and, in his or her mind, exposes an inability and unworthiness in obtaining and holding onto the things people deserve to pursue. Even if the person holds some, or the majority of, responsibility in the loss, what was lost was probably imperfect and the behaviors that led to the loss are changeable. We’re human, and life is usually a trial-and-error thing.

Myths can also amplify the lack of purpose one feels after losing a job, becoming hospitalized, or losing a relationship. This is particularly true if the loss involved something the person felt defined them: “This is who I was, and now that it’s gone, where does that leave me?” Myths can hold us to the belief that purpose is unchangeable and who we were before the loss was the best we could have been.

In reality, there may have been significant problems and costs to the identity that we were not attentive to; these costs may have been a factor in causing the loss. Myths hold us back from an honest analysis of what led us to “the problem,” which in turn, prevents us from changing our behaviors or priorities in a way that works for us now. Myths can make us risk-averse, because if it can’t be the same, what’s the point? The answer is that “it” being different may be what we need, and the loss could be used as a wake-up call. In holding onto myths, we may reenact patterns and behaviors that are maladaptive.

When the loss involves a person who was both a family member and a perpetrator, myths can act as an obstacle to accessing traumatic content. Survivors of childhood abuse utilize several strategies to survive their environments and maintain a positive view of those they love because of the meaning that relationship may have in their minds (“she is my mother; I’m supposed to love her”). From their perspective, pushing for change may have a greater cost than living with it. This capacity or inclination can prevent survivors from feeling as if they have permission to think about the person they lost in a negative light. These are common issues for any trauma survivor, but holding on to the myth after a loss may make the work in acknowledging and processing the trauma that much harder.

Within a familial context, myths can create a perceived demand for adherence to a “story” that may feel objectionable to some within the family. Trauma survivors can feel uncomfortable in processing the loss authentically with those they may feel closest to for fear of making waves or hurting them.

Grounding ourselves in fact can go a long way in helping us cope with a loss. Being factual means focusing on what we know, not what we believe, so that we can derive a reasonable meaning from the loss experience. It allows us to acknowledge and mourn the good while identifying what was harmful so that the work of adaptive grieving and behavior change can move forward.

One important aspect of remaining factual is communicating the emotional and cognitive content we hold to another person we trust. This allows us to expose any distorted beliefs or thinking to another person’s logic and perception. This is important because it creates an external brace against unreasonable thinking. By not allowing exposure, the only thing left to challenge the distorted narrative is the source of it.

Family, friends, and other natural supports (priests, rabbis, the lady who does your nails) are usually the best options if safety is not an issue because they represent long-term, sustainable resources you can access anytime. If safety is an issue or you are experiencing symptoms that go beyond a normal grief reaction, seeking professional help (therapists, psychiatrists, medical doctor) can provide more intensive support and a greater assurance of confidentiality.

© Copyright 2013 All rights reserved.

The preceding article was solely written by the author named above. Any views and opinions expressed are not necessarily shared by Questions or concerns about the preceding article can be directed to the author or posted as a comment below.

  • Leave a Comment
  • KJP

    February 6th, 2013 at 4:01 AM

    This is interesting, because i watch my own wife struglle with this.
    Her father died when she was young, and from everything that I have heard about him he was an alcoholic who wasn’t very kind to others.
    But I find that my wife has created in her mind something far more than what he actualy was. I think that this is her way of trying to cope with having not had this role in her life. So this is what she wants it to be.
    But i see how this drives a wedge between her and her mother as her mom is willing to be honest but my wife chooses to remain in denial about her daf.

  • Avery

    February 6th, 2013 at 9:39 AM

    I think it is interesting the put two and two together in terms of romanticizing someone after loss if you have depression or anxiety before the loss. I would never have even thought to explore that possibility. I guess that’s why I don’t make the big bucks!

  • Carmella

    February 6th, 2013 at 9:42 AM

    This article made me laugh. I was talking to a friend of 50+ years about my husband who I lost five years ago. I was going on and on about how wonderful he was and how much fun we had together. My friend looked at me like I was crazy. She reminded me of all the times we used to argue and fuss. While we loved each other, our relationship was not one of those smooth sailing ones. Cracked me up!

  • Burt G.

    February 6th, 2013 at 9:48 AM

    My wife calls this “revisionist history.” Her mom is always telling us how wonderful her kids were growing up, how they never fought, etc etc. To hear my wife tell it, they fought like cats and dogs on most days. But, I think her mom really mourns and grieve over her kids growing up and leaving home. She put so much of herself into raising her kids that is hard for her now that they don’t need her anymore. So, I think she kind of glorifies those days.

  • Oifa Gomez

    February 6th, 2013 at 9:52 AM

    I like the idea of bouncing feelings surrounding grief off of someone else. Often that person has a much more objective view of the person who was lost than the person who is grieving.

  • Donald

    February 6th, 2013 at 11:27 PM

    Never easy to get over the end of a relationship. My brother has been so distraught after his marriage ended a year ago. He refuses to talk to us, his family, openly about it and remains depressed most of the time. His depression even manifests into anger and conflict many times.

    I am really concerned about him and I just hope he decides to come out of it and try to share it. Because sometimes just sharing it may be what is needed to get rid of the pain inside. Bottling it all inside is NOT going to help.

  • Liam

    February 8th, 2013 at 11:09 AM

    Why is it that when we lose someone so early in our life or those, we do tend to idealize them, idolize them even, and set them up on this pedestal whether they belong there or not.

Leave a Comment

By commenting you acknowledge acceptance of's Terms and Conditions of Use.


* Indicates required field.

GoodTherapy uses cookies to personalize content and ads to provide better services for our users and to analyze our traffic. By continuing to use this site you consent to our cookies.