Living with Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde

I recently stumbled across a new blog called Infinite Daze where the author poignantly writes about her daily struggles with Fibromyalgia and Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS).  In a recent post titled Should I Stay or Should I Go Now, she has this to say about her marriage:

“I had a revelation today. During my son’s graduation ceremony at his high school, my husband came up to me and squatted down next to my wheelchair to share a story with me. Without thinking I ran my hand over his hair and down his arm. I’m still in love with this guy. He can be very nice. He can be very sweet. I married him because of this. This is why I find his behavior so baffling. I’ve known this guy just shy of 25 years. That is a long time. The meanness, the temper tantrums, the spitefulness is all new. I’ve never seen this in him before. Living with someone for 25 years means this isn’t behavior that has been hidden away. It is brand spanking new. It is why I’ve been blindsided with it. I so didn’t see this coming. It also makes the whole idea of divorce so messy. If he was always nasty this would be a no-brainer. I would up and leave in a heartbeat. But he swings hot and cold. One day he is super nice to me; takes good care of me and even gives me hugs. The next day he is slamming doors and telling me he wants out. I am so very confused.”

Ever feel like you’re living with Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde? Your partner is warm, loving and compassionate one moment and angry, silent or indifferent the next.  What’s up with that? You’ve most likely rubbed your partner’s “raw spot.”

We all struggle with vulnerable feelings in love whether we want to admit it or not. It’s inevitable that we will hurt each other with careless words or selfish actions. While these occasions sting, the pain is often fleeting and we get over it quickly. But according to Dr. Sue Johnson, founder of Emotionally Focused Therapy, almost all of us have at least one hypersensitivity – a raw spot in our emotional skin– that is tender to the touch, easily rubbed, and deeply painful.  When this spot gets rubbed often enough, it can bleed all over our relationship.

For those of us in chronic marriages, this hypersensitivity can emerge seemingly out of nowhere at the onset of our illness when the need for support from our partner is particularly intense, but it doesn’t come. When our need for attachment and connection is repeatedly neglected, ignored or dismissed, it results in two potential raw spots: feeling emotionally deprived or deserted/abandoned.

I know my raw spot rather well. When I hear a tone of impatience in my husband’s voice (chronic illness-related or not), I get angry and defensive. It sends me back to days when my father would dismiss me as not being important or worthy enough of his time. My father’s impatience was his way of disconnecting from the relationship. This experience made me hypersensitive – impatience signals emotional abandonment to me.

Many of us have no idea what our own raw spots are, let alone our partners’.  We simply get caught up in the same old vicious cycle of petty squabbles and conflicts when in actuality they are symptoms of a raw and tender spot on our emotional skin.

So how do you identify your raw spot?

Think about a time in your marriage when you got suddenly thrown off balance, when a small response or lack of response suddenly seemed to change your sense of safety or connection with your spouse, or when you got totally caught up in reacting in a way that you knew would spiral you into your usual dysfunctional pattern of relating. Maybe you are aware of a moment when you found yourself reacting very angrily or numbing out.

Let’s unpack this incident:

  • What was happening in the relationship?  What was the trigger that created a sense of emotional disconnection for you?  What was your general feeling in the split second before you reacted and got mad or numb?  What did your spouse specifically do or say that sparked this response?
  • As you think of a moment when your own raw spot is rubbed, what happens to your body?  You might feel spacey, detached, hot, breathless, tight in the chest, very small, empty, shaky, tearful, cold, on fire.
  • What does your brain decide about the meaning of all this?  What do you say to yourself when this happens?
  • What did you do then?  How do you move into action?
  • See if you can tie in all these elements together by filling in the blanks below:

In this incident, the trigger for my raw feeling was _________.  On the surface, I probably showed _____________.  But deep down, I just felt (pick one of the basic negative emotions, sadness, anger, shame, fear).  What I longed for was ___________.  The main message I got about our bond, about me or my love was _________________.

Here are some common scenarios:

You experience a flare-up and it’s worse than usual. You are really struggling and looking for support and empathy from your husband.  He begins to suggest ways you can get your flare-up under control. You hear his suggestions as him lecturing you. In your head you say to yourself, “He’s judging me.  He’s not with me in this. I have to do this all on my own. My need for support doesn’t matter. This is scary”.  What happens next? You start yelling and tell him he’s a jerk and you don’t need his help anyway.

Or how about this scenario?

Your husband asks you to watch a movie with him on the couch after dinner. Your head is pounding from a migraine and you tell him you’re tired and going to bed. The next morning you ask him if a certain outfit looks good on you. He says “it’s OK but since when does my opinion really make a difference here? Wear what you want. What I want is irrelevant.” Still stuck in feelings of rejection from the previous night, his sadness over lack of connection with you force him into withdrawal and giving you the silent treatment.

In both scenarios, rage and withdrawal mask the emotions that are central in vulnerability: sadness, shame, and most of all, fear.

If you find yourself continually stuck in an unhealthy pattern of relating with your spouse, you can bet it is being sparked by attempts to deal with the pain of a sore spot, or more likely, sore spots in both of you. And unfortunately, your raw spots almost inevitably rub against your spouse’s. Rub one in your spouse, and his or her reaction often irritates one in you.

What’s the dead giveaway that tells you your raw spot or your spouse’s raw spot has been hit?

First, there is a sudden and radical shift in the emotional tone of the conversation. You and your spouse were joking just a minute ago, but now one of you is upset or angry, or, conversely, aloof and cold. You are thrown off balance. It’s as if the rules changed and no one told you.

Second, your spouse’s reaction to a perceived offense seems way out of proportion.

These signs are all about attachment needs and fears popping up. They are all about our deepest and most powerful emotions suddenly taking over. We get set to move in a particular way, toward, away from, or against our spouse. This readiness to act is wired into every emotion. Anger tells us to approach and fight. Shame tells us to withdraw and hide.  Fear tells us to flee or freeze, or in real extremes to turn back and attack back. Sadness tells us to grieve and let go.

All this happens in a nanosecond.

Stopping these destructive patterns depends not only on identifying and stopping our unhealthy ways of relating but also on finding and soothing our raw spots and helping our spouse to do the same.

Here’s how you do just that:

  1. Stop the Game – one or both of you has to say “Can we stop this?  This is the place we always go.  We get trapped here and we end up totally exhausted and defeated.”
  2. Claim Your Own Moves – together come up with a short summary of your moves.  e.g. you lose it while your spouse pretends not to be affected; you get louder and threaten; your spouse sees you as impossible and withdraws.
  3. Claim Your Own Feelings – talk about your own feelings rather than focusing on your spouse and blaming everything on him/her.
  4. Own How You Shape Your Partner’s Feelings – Recognize how your usual way of dealing with your emotions pulls your spouse off balance and turns on deeper attachment fears.
  5. Ask About Your Partner’s Deeper Emotions – Look at the big picture and slow down a little.  Begin to be curious about your spouse’s softer, underlying emotions, rather than just listening to your own hurts and fears and assuming the worst about your spouse.
  6. Share Your Own Deeper, Softer Emotions – Although voicing your deepest emotions, especially fears around not being connected or attached to your spouse, may be the most difficult step for you, it is also the most rewarding.  Let your spouse see what’s really at stake when you argue.
  7. Stand Together – Take the above steps and forge a renewed and true partnership.  You now have a common ground and cause.  You no longer see each other as enemies but allies.  You can take control of escalating negative conversations that feed your insecurities and face those insecurities together.

Content for this article has been adapted from the book Hold Me Tight by Dr. Sue Johnson.

© Copyright 2011 by Helena Madsen, MA. All Rights Reserved. Permission to publish granted to

The preceding article was solely written by the author named above. Any views and opinions expressed are not necessarily shared by Questions or concerns about the preceding article can be directed to the author or posted as a comment below.

  • Leave a Comment
  • Jake

    July 8th, 2011 at 5:42 PM

    A wonderful article regarding a problem that is very much prevalent in relationships all over.I have been through something like this with my wife many a times but never really knew what was behind this or the reason for it. I’m happy to have come across this article. Thanks a lot.

  • tabitha w

    July 8th, 2011 at 11:57 PM

    it can be very tough living with someone like husband is somewhat like this but I know that deep down in his heart his feelings towards me are genuine and that he loves me.and my faith and the knowledge of his love keeps me strong when he suddenly turns into a completely different and rude person.

  • James

    July 9th, 2011 at 12:14 AM

    Truly a great read, thank you very much! Especially the bolded numeric points at the end – I can relate to those so well.

  • mills

    July 9th, 2011 at 5:06 AM

    uh oh- what with my mood swings and horrible pms I know that my husband must feel like he lives with Jekyll and Hyde too.
    But sometimes you can’t help your emotions. You can’t just throw a rug over them and pretend like they are not there.
    And don’t I deserve to vent every now and then too? Not at the expense of others feelings but I have to be able to let it all out otherwise I would go crazy!

  • Brad

    July 10th, 2011 at 10:24 AM

    Good grief, it is enough to know my own raw spots, much less have to deal with those of a spouse. Looks to me like people need to do a little growing up before they get married and then these sorts of mole hills do not have to become quite the mountains that they are made out to be!

  • Carin Hancock

    July 12th, 2011 at 2:13 PM

    @mills: You are absolutely right. You have the right to vent once in a while, but like you said, not at another person’s expense. Taking your anger out on another is selfish at best and damaging to you both and your relationship at worst.

    It also makes you look like a nasty old witch that can’t keep herself in check. Is that the image you want to present of yourself to the world? I doubt it. Get some help for your pms symptoms from your doctor and you’ll feel much better. With medication, life can improve.

  • Mary

    November 30th, 2012 at 9:34 AM

    Sometimes this occurs when a spouse becomes ill or has low blodd sugar. It will not cure the instances but will help the understanding of what they may be feeling. My Husband feels like he is being shredded on the inside whn he lashes out like this.

  • Daniel

    March 22nd, 2019 at 2:40 PM

    This article is exceptionally helpful, and I am amazed that it is freely shared. The initial explanation, introspective walkthrough, and therapeutic advice (geared towards those in relationships, though it can be applied to an individual’s self development without that relationship aspect) all completes a package that makes further reading almost unnecessary, though personally I recommend a continued pursuit of self awareness, regardless.

    Thank go to Good Therapy, for posting this, Helena Madsen, for writing this, and Dr. Sue Johnson, for the source material.

  • Tammy

    April 21st, 2019 at 9:58 AM

    How do you fix it when your partner refuses to talk, refuses to acknowledge your in the room, and when he does speak its name calling and put downs

  • Daniel

    April 22nd, 2019 at 1:38 PM

    Tammy, I am not educated, trained, or certified so do not take my word for anything, but there is so much more to know than what you’ve shared.
    Ask yourself: has something triggered this behaviour or has it always been this way? Multiple triggers could be working together to cause it; stress, trauma, narcissism, etc.
    These behaviours are control tactics and immature, as well as equatable with a form of abuse. Are you dependant on this relationship? Emotionally, socially, physically?
    Two points to take away; You should be aware of other options, and you may not be able to change someone.
    Therefore 1) Have a backup plan (i.e. a safe place to go, or the authority to remove your partner from your place, depending on the situation), 2) Invite your partner to have a discussion about their feelings and thoughts, or to enter therapy/councelling so they can express themselves with a professional and then later with you, in sessions or at home. Otherwise be prepared to end the relationship. (There are good people out there. Hard to find, but they exist, so don’t feel trapped!)
    I don’t know if this was in any way helpful, remember, I am not a professional.
    Good luck.

  • Edith Gr

    July 15th, 2019 at 3:20 PM

    Tammy, mine does the same thing. Or, he’ll throw in the silent treatment for a week. He never will tell me what I did wrong. Therefore, it’s bound to happen time after time. At this point, I feel it’s not even worth the last bit of energy I have to even argue or disagree with him.

  • Christine

    June 1st, 2021 at 10:09 AM

    This is a real syndrome. I live with it on a daily basis, my husband has suffered from Jekyll and Hyde for ten years. The emotional roller coaster is taxing at best. To you guys who don’t know, please don’t comment. It is degrading.

  • Daniel

    June 2nd, 2021 at 4:15 PM

    Christine, I have to say sorry. I suspect your comment was directed at myself. You are correct, and I have a lot to learn about many things. Hope all goes well for you.

  • Robin

    May 1st, 2023 at 7:07 AM

    I am 67 and trapped financially in a Jekyll and Hyde relationship. I don’t feel he really loves me but will do very nice things for me and then turn around and be a complete jerk. I don’t make things any better because I lose it and lash in anger. I am sick of it and want out but don’t know how to make it happen. I feel too old to start over and have too many issues physically with a bad knee etc to move out on my own. We have been married for 13 years and things get worse. There are times he acts normal than I catch him in a lie or he just acts so weird that I am thrown off balance again. Sometimes it’s like he does it on purpose. I am very sad and depressed and don’t know what to do. I’ve tried to get a counselor but have not been able to. At this point I just want out. Does anyone have any suggestions. Thank you

Leave a Comment

By commenting you acknowledge acceptance of's Terms and Conditions of Use.


* Indicates required field.

GoodTherapy uses cookies to personalize content and ads to provide better services for our users and to analyze our traffic. By continuing to use this site you consent to our cookies.