You may know someone who is depressed and not know they’re depressed. People expect someone who is depressed to cry a lot, stay in bed all day, mope, or sound like Eeyore from Winnie the Pooh. But depression isn’t always this obvious.

Some people can totally fake it. They can smile and laugh; they can act like everyone else, even while they are in excruciating emotional pain. Occasionally people who can do this end up killing themselves, and no one can believe it. People who are depressed but act like they are fine may not confide in anyone. Usually they find a way to spend time alone crying or letting down the facade and then go back to acting when they have to be with people. I’ve had clients who lived with their families and only found time to cry after everyone went to sleep, and only in the bathroom. The rest of the time they were acting like someone who wasn’t in pain. On top of the pain they already feel, acting happy is emotionally exhausting, and having this secret is isolating. So, faking it can even increase the depression.

Others funnel their pain into anger and people see them rage, abuse, shame, or react with annoyance or irritation to whatever happens around them. They may or may not themselves know they’re depressed, but others often don’t guess how much devastating emotional pain they are in. People may fear them, despise them, or dismiss them as mean. It is very difficult to feel sympathy for someone who is hurting people, and it is difficult to see their vulnerability, so their depression goes unnoticed.

[fat_widget_depression_right]

Still others are addicted to something, and the depression is obscured by the addiction. People with addictions spend most of their time and energy relating to the addiction. They plan to do it, anticipate doing it—these phases excite them and elevate their mood temporarily. Then they use whatever they are addicted to and it boosts their mood. But the thrill wears off, and they are depleted by the effects of the addiction and may also feel remorse or shame, so the depression descends on them, pulling them down like a cement jacket. They begin the cycle again to try to feel better; they plan and anticipate. Their whole life is about running from depression, but it becomes centered around the more dramatic force of addiction, and the depression can be unrecognized. I am not saying that all addicts are driven by depression—depression can also be caused by addiction. But addiction can be a form depression takes that is not easy to identify as depression. I include eating disorders in this category. I also include people who work most of their waking hours.

Depression isolates people. Whether they are hiding from the world in bed, preoccupied with an addiction, pushing people away with anger, or keeping their real thoughts and feelings inside while pretending to be okay, people with depression usually feel very alone.

Depression isolates people. Whether they are hiding from the world in bed, preoccupied with an addiction, pushing people away with anger, or keeping their real thoughts and feelings inside while pretending to be okay, people with depression usually feel very alone. Depression also has a built-in isolating fog quality that makes it very difficult to feel connected to people. Even when people feel safe to express exactly how they feel, it is very difficult for people who haven’t experienced a deep depression to understand how that feels. How can anyone who hasn’t experienced it understand a pain that is as intense as any open-heart surgery without anesthesia, with no cuts or bruises to show? How can anyone who hasn’t experienced it understand the complexity of pain that is not only unbearably intense itself but also complicated by many painful factors like the stigma of mental illness and the confusion of the fact that unlike other illnesses, depression causes behavior changes. People attribute behavior to the moral character of the person, rather than to the illness.

The pain is also complicated by the fact that depression attacks a person’s thoughts and feelings, rather than liver or lungs. Depression can cause a person to think she hates herself or is unhappy in her relationships. It can cause someone to believe everyone would be better off without him, or even that others would be better off dead. It can cause people to feel sad, angry, guilty, numb, or rageful, even when none of this is how they feel when they aren’t depressed.

So what can you do to help people you love who are depressed, if you can’t tell they’re depressed? Ask questions very kindly and listen to the answers very carefully. Empathize with their emotional pain—even if you have to guess at what it might be. Let them know you are there to listen and understand for as long as it takes, and you aren’t taking no for an answer. Of course if you aren’t trustworthy—if you judge them, or talk to others about what they tell you, or interrupt, get impatient, or misunderstand them, then it is better for them to talk to someone who can really listen without any of this. Being a reliable, trustworthy, patient, nonjudgmental listener is the best thing you can do in most cases with someone who is depressed.

A couple of caveats: I am talking about adults—children and teens require some variations. Also, addictions cloud the picture of depression and require their own, very different intervention. Nonjudgmental listening is still essential but may need to be combined with some firm boundary-setting and professional treatment for the addiction.

A client that drops out of therapy is one who does not complete the recommended course of treatment. Many therapeutic approaches, such as cognitive behavioral therapy, do not have a specific treatment deadline, and clients are considered dropouts when they have voluntarily stopped therapy prior to resolving the issues and symptoms that brought them there to begin with. Dropout is a serious concern for the medical community and the general population. Individuals who drop out of therapy are more likely to have future psychological complications and seek services multiple times, which places an economic burden on society. Because they do not learn adaptive coping strategies and fail to address the issues that plague them most seriously, they are likely to be less than productive in their careers, families, and communities. Additionally, therapists who experience client dropout may begin to question their ability to help clients and their own adequacy.

Understanding the factors that contribute to dropout can provide clinicians with the information they need to address the problem. Joshua K. Swift of the Department of Psychology at the University of Alaska in Anchorage wanted to explore this problem further and made it the focus of his most recent study. Swift analyzed over 650 studies that included more than 83,000 clients and looked at factors such as client age, therapy setting, therapist experience, type of therapy, issues addressed in therapy, and clinician definition of dropout.

Swift found that nearly 20% of all the clients in the studies ended their treatment early. He found that some variables, such as therapy setting, influenced the rates of dropout. He also discovered that rates of dropout were highest among the youngest participants and those seeking treatment for personality or eating problems. Swift believes that more work is needed to determine specific nuances that effect retention. He hopes efforts will be aimed at isolating psychological issues, such as anxiety or depression, and approaches, such as psychodynamic or behavioral therapy, in order to get a clearer idea of the different dimensions affecting treatment completion. Swift said, “By paying attention to these variables and making adaptations where needed, clinicians may be able to reduce rates of premature discontinuation in their work with clients.”

Reference:
Swift, J. K., Greenberg, R. P. (2012). Premature discontinuation in adult psychotherapy: A meta-analysis. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology80.4: 547-559.

If you don’t get the right nutrients, your body won’t function to the best of its ability. Some general health conditions can be linked to nutritional deficiency, but it’s up for debate whether the same applies to specific mental health conditions. Some nutrition experts do claim that unique cases of social anxiety can actually be caused by a nutritional deficiency. In the condition several experts refer to as pyroluria, once the nutritional deficiency is taken care of, the social anxiety is relieved. Other experts are quick to dismiss the validity of this diagnosis.

Trudy Scott, a food-and-mood expert who said in an email that she has suffered from pyroluria, is a certified nutritionist, immediate past president of the National Association of Nutrition Professionals, and author of The Antianxiety Food Solution: How the Foods You Eat Can Help You Calm Your Anxious Mind, Improve Your Mood and End Cravings.

“The person experiences shyness, inner tension, and social anxiety,” Scott said in regard to symptoms of pyroluria. “Symptoms usually start in childhood and are made worse under stressful situations. The wonderful thing is that the symptoms can be completely alleviated with taking these supplements: zinc, vitamin B6, and evening primrose oil. People typically start to feel less anxious, less shy, and more social within a week. The important thing is that if you do have pyroluria, you do need to take the supplements always.”

Generally only zinc and Vitamin B6 are recommended for pyroluria, but “gamma-linolenic acid (GLA), found in evening primrose oil and borage oil, is also beneficial for those with pyroluria because its levels are often low, and supplementing with GLA improves zinc absorption,” she added. In her book about anxiety, mood, and food, she wrote a whole chapter about pyroluria.

“I am … very passionate about the subject because I have pyroluria myself and used to suffer terribly from social phobia and shyness, anxiety, unexplained fears, waking with a sense of doom and even panic attacks,” Scott said. “I have used the amazing healing powers of foods and nutrients to completely heal. I now help women find natural solutions for anxiety and other mood disorders.”

She has posted a questionnaire on her website for pyroluria. It includes a long list of symptoms, and if 15 or more items are checked on the list, it is likely a person has pyroluria: http://www.everywomanover29.com/blog/pyroluria-questionnaire-from-the-antianxiety-food-solution/

She said that in research studies, pyroluria is also called “the mauve factor.” “Much of what we know about pyroluria is based on the work of Humphrey Osmond, Abram Hoffer, and Carl Pfeiffer,” Scott said. “Much of the original work was done with schizophrenic patients in psychiatric hospital settings. Although pyroluria was first identified in the 1960s, the medical and mental health communities have been slow to recognize it, and many mental health practitioners and physicians remain unfamiliar with this condition.”

She said she learned about the condition mainly from reading the following books:
The Mood Cure by Julia Ross
Depression-Free Naturally by Joan Mathews-Larson
Nutrition and Mental Illness (1988) by Carl Pfeiffer

Her own book goes into the specific details and biological/chemical/genetic aspects of pyroluria. In her book, she cites research prevalence rates from Joan Mathews-Larson, the author of Depression-Free Naturally. Pyroluria is thought to exist in “11 percent of the healthy population” and “40 percent of adults with psychiatric disorders,” according to Scott’s book. For people with alcohol addiction, pyroluria is thought to have a 40% prevalence rate. However, the prevalence rates do depend on the source. In her own experience as a nutritionist, Scott said about 80% of her clients who have moderate to severe anxiety have symptoms associated with pyroluria.

She added that stress can be a major factor for what age pyroluria develops and that it is a genetic condition that seems to affect more women than men. In addition, people who have pyroluria tend to also have gluten sensitivity, especially if they also are dealing with other issues like depression, anxiety, autism, alcoholism, bipolar disorder, and schizophrenia, according to the book. People with pyroluria may also have digestive problems, and they need to make sure to balance out an increased Vitamin B intake with a higher intake of magnesium.

In the book The Mood Cure by Julia Ross, the author includes a discussion of the prevalence, testing, and treatment of pyroluria, as well as a checklist similar to that offered by Trudy Scott. Ross states that the questionnaire was developed by Dr. Carl Pfeiffer, a clinician and researcher. He wrote the book Nutrition and Mental Illness: An Orthomolecular Approach to Balancing Body Chemistry in 1988.

Ross states in her book that pyroluria is fairly uncommon in the general public, but in certain groups of people (like those who have experienced alcohol addiction), it is more common. “I am just getting familiar with this condition, but I can see that it is an important one for certain people, affecting stress levels and mood generally and preventing full response to nutrient therapy until it is addressed,” Ross wrote in her book.

There are a plethora of articles dedicated to nutrition, diet, and mental health in general, as well as multiple research studies suggesting that certain mental health issues can be improved through natural supplements and a healthy overall diet. “Notably, essential vitamins, minerals, and omega-3 fatty acids are often deficient in the general population in America and other developed countries and are exceptionally deficient in patients suffering from mental disorders,” according to an abstract from a research study in Nutrition Journal. “Studies have shown that daily supplements of vital nutrients often effectively reduce patients’ symptoms.”

Another abstract from a research article in the journal Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine concludes the following: “Many patients will benefit from the use of specific dietary supplements, such as a multivitamin-mineral high in B vitamins and omega-3 fatty acid,” according to the abstract. “And no matter what the underlying cause of the mood disorder, patients should be counseled about the relationship between food and mood, for the evidence now substantiates what laypeople and medical professionals have long known intuitively: the way we eat affects the way we feel.”

The research, authored by Tieraona Low Dog, director of the fellowship at Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine at University of Arizona, added in the research abstract that the healthiest diet for improving mental health is a “low-glycemic, modified Mediterranean diet rich in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and seafood (if not vegetarian) and low in processed, refined foods.”

Other experts remain unaware of the condition and are skeptical of its legitimacy. Scott Carroll, a psychiatrist with dual board certifications in adult and child and adolescent psychiatry, said in an email that he is not accustomed to pyroluria and had to look it up on Google to find out what it was.

“Once I saw that it is connected to orthomolecular psychiatry, which I have heard of, I knew it was in the pseudoscience realm,” said Carroll, who is also an assistant professor at the University of New Mexico School of Medicine. “Not surprisingly, it claims to be the cause of a number of unrelated psychiatric disorders, which is typical of pseudoscience disorders. Like so many ‘cure-alls,’ it sounds plausible, but there is no scientific basis to it, and it allows dubious practitioners to prey on desperate, suffering people.”

He said there are certain cases where nutrition can play a part in mood and mental disorders. “Inadequate amounts of Omega 3 fatty acids, especially from fish or krill oil, have been shown to affect mood and anxiety in a broad way of which social anxiety can be a part,” Carroll said. “Also, low folate, low Vitamin D, and low B12 have all been associated with negative effects on mood and anxiety.”

“However, in people with low folate, it is more often a case of a genetic inability to transport the folate molecule into the brain rather than a low blood level,” he added. “In those cases, which often present with chronic depression and anxiety that has never responded to antidepressants, there are folate precursors that are more lipophilic and can diffuse into the brain without use of a transport mechanism.”

Nerina Garcia-Arcement, a licensed clinical psychologist and clinical assistant professor at the NYU School of Medicine, said in an email that she didn’t study pyroluria in school and hasn’t read about it in any research studies after graduating from her doctorate program.

“Based on current knowledge it does not appear to be a legitimate health condition,” Garcia-Arcement said. “Further research is required to further explore and understand whether social anxiety or any other mental health condition could be related to improper synthesis in the blood.  Although this theory seems appealing, being able to ‘cure’ a mental disorder with vitamins or supplements … is unlikely.”

“Causes of social anxiety that have been substantiated by research include chemical imbalances in the brain (i.e., serotonin, a neurotransmitter), inherited traits (genetic and through observing anxious family members), negative life events or experiences, and an overactive amygdala (a part of the brain that controls emotions, including fear response),” she added.

She said that good nutrition is important for overall health, but it’s not necessarily linked to mental disorders. “In my experience, the social anxiety could be traced to other causes, not nutritional deficiencies,” Garcia-Arcement said. “Having a healthy and balanced diet is overall beneficial, but it won’t cure social anxiety or a mood disorder. I am more likely to recommend my clients get enough sun exposure to improve their moods (seasonal affective disorder) than recommend diet changes.”

Related articles:
Social Anxiety Can Be a Hidden Problem in College
Breathing Lessons
The Birth of Anxiety

People in their 20s seem to have it all: youth, energy, health, and looks. But they are also still figuring themselves out, and this time of change can bring certain mental health concerns as well. Experts have information on these issues that tend to impact people in their 20s, and provide some solutions for addressing and coping with these problems.

Clinical psychologist Dean Haddock, a marriage, family, and child counselor and the executive director and founder of Community Counseling and Psychological Services, points to a fairly common activity of 20-somethings that can lead to mental health issues if it’s not checked: alcohol and drug use.

“The first problem that leads to many others is alcohol and chemical abuse, which often leads to dependency,” Haddock said in an email. “The mental disorders that follow are often depression, anxiety, and brain injury. Of course, self-esteem and body-image problems often lead to eating disorders.”

Haddock gives three tips to help people in their 20s prevent and get through some common mental health concerns:

1. Know your genetic history of mental disorders. Knowing is half the battle to avoid those disorders in yourself.
2. Be choosey about your friends, as they will influence your decisions. Healthy friends lead to healthier decisions.
3. Self-esteem is often the result of the people who matter to you. If they do not esteem you, then you will not esteem yourself.

Nerina Garcia-Arcement, a clinical psychologist and clinical assistant professor at NYU School of Medicine, suggests that the many life changes people experience in their 20s can cause mental health issues at times.

“Your 20s are filled with life transitions that can be stressful,” Garcia-Arcement said. “This is a time when young adults are solidifying their personalities, developing their independence from family, starting or finishing college, beginning new jobs, developing a career, forming romantic relationships, and learning to manage their existing family relationships and friendships within these context.”

“Individuals in their 20s don’t have a lifetime of experience to draw on when managing multiple life transitions at once,” she added. “When someone experiences these transitions, anxiety and depressive disorders can occur.”

Here are six of Garcia-Arcement’s tips to help people in their 20s cope with mental health issues more common to that age group:

1. Seek out and form strong support networks.
2. Seek out others who are going through similar experiences and share your feelings, whether you are feeling worried, nervous, scared, sad, confused, or excited.
3. Know that you are not alone in your confusion about your career and relationships.
4. Seek out mentors who have achieved their goals, and ask for advice.
5. If you are feeling stress, sadness, or anxiety, engage in activities that will help you manage those feelings such as yoga, meditation, exercise, hobbies, social activities, relaxation exercises, and deep breathing.
6. If you feel you are not getting the necessary support and feel overwhelmed or depressed, seek out mental health professionals who can help you manage the feelings related to your life transitions.

Stephanie Sarkis, a licensed mental health counselor, said in an email that anxiety and depression are some of the main mental health issues 20-somethings face.

“We have seen an increase in these issues due to the lagging economy and difficulties finding employment,” Sarkis said. “Many people in their 20s have moved back in with their parents, which can trigger feelings of failure and frustration.”

Dr. Maiysha Clairborne, a family physician and wellness and stress management coach, added in an email that eating disorders associated with body dysmorphic disorder and body-image issues are also common for people in their 20s. She has three overall tips for people in this age group:

1. Talk to someone. The worst thing that a person can do when they are feeling depressed, anxious, or alone is to isolate more. Many times when we talk with someone we trust about what’s going on, we come to realize that we are not the only ones experiencing it and then we can get support.
2. Get active. Staying physically active not only helps to keep the body fit but also helps release endorphins and serotonin in the brain, which help keep the mood elevated. Physical activity is also a good release for stress and anxiety.
3. Minimize sugar and junk food. Sugar and processed junk foods can worsen the emotions of stress, anxiety, and depression because they cause erratic changes in your body’s blood sugars. This can disrupt the normal release of hormones in the brain that keep your moods stable.

Scott Carroll, a psychiatrist with dual board certifications in adult and child and adolescent psychiatry, said there are many issues specific to people in their 20s, including problems associated with medication use.

“Many people were on stimulants/meds for their ADHD when they were younger, but they thought it was okay to stop their meds when they were done with school,” Carroll said. “Now they are struggling at work and don’t know why. I’ve also seen young adults stop all kinds of meds like their thyroid meds because they didn’t know why they were even on it, and then they have all kinds of problems.”

Bad habits involving drug and alcohol use can start to become a major substance abuse issue when people are in their 20s, and other mental health issues start coming to the forefront at this time in peoples’ lives. Examples include bipolar disorder and schizophrenia. Also, panic attacks can start for people who have a genetic predisposition and who have higher amounts of stress associated with newfound adulthood.

“The 20s are an important time of social/emotional development,” Carroll said. “Unlike previous generations, identity formation often takes the entire 20s due to the complexity of modern society. It could be said that adolescence lasts until the early 30s in today’s society due to [prolonged] periods of education (grad school, law school, med school, etc.), lack of stable job options, and delays in getting married and starting families.”

Carroll, who is also an assistant professor at the University of New Mexico School of Medicine, suggests that when it comes to serious relationships and marriage, people in their 20s should consider how their choices could eventually affect their mental health and how their brain plays a part in their decision.

“Many 20-somethings are tempted to get married, but it is generally a bad idea because the brain in not done developing until about 25 [years old] … which leaves young adults vulnerable to having their rational mind be overwhelmed by their feelings or stress,” Carroll said. “Relationship choices often dramatically change from the early 20s to the late 20s, so many people find that the person that was perfect at 22 is a disaster at 27.  This can be an incredibly hard transition, to have to break up with your former soul mate that you thought you’d love for life because you’ve changed so much over the last several years.”

Related articles:
Do I Have a Healthy Relationship With Food and My Body?
Social Anxiety Can Be a Hidden Problem in College
How Schools Could Prevent Depression

Depression and self-esteem are intertwined and contribute to negative affect. Research has shown how self-esteem influences depression, and some studies have suggested that depression works negatively to decrease self-esteem. Understanding how each of these conditions affects the other is essential in order to effectively treat depression and other conditions that co-occur such as anxiety. In an attempt to determine the nature of the relationship between depressive symptoms and self-esteem, Julia Friederike Sowislo of the Department of Psychology at the University of Basel in Switzerland conducted a review of existing research on these conditions.

Sowislo analyzed 18 studies on anxiety and self-esteem and an additional 77 studies on depression and self-esteem. She looked at the vulnerability factors of each symptom and assessed the impact they had on each other. The data she reviewed were collected from individuals ranging in age from early childhood to late adulthood. The studies Sowislo chose were conducted using a variety of measurements and time periods, allowing for a broad review of data.

[fat_widget_right]

The final analyses revealed a strong relationship between self-esteem and depression but a weak one for depression and self-esteem. Specifically, Sowislo found that decreases in self-esteem were predictive of increases in depression. But she found only minimal evidence for depression decreasing self-esteem. However, when she looked at self-esteem and anxiety, Sowislo found that the relationship was more reciprocal, with both self-esteem and anxiety negatively affecting each other in similar ways. These findings provide additional and clear evidence of the importance of self-esteem in depression. “The robustness of the effect also strengthens the potential importance of self-esteem interventions,” said Sowislo. She believes that treatments aimed at reducing depression by way of improving self-esteem could provide not only short-term gains for clients but also long-term protection from depression for those most at risk. Sowislo added that regardless of age or gender, individuals should be taught how to improve their sense of self-worth in order to effectively manage and overcome their depression.

Reference:
Sowislo, J. F., Orth, U. (2012). Does low self-esteem predict depression and anxiety? A meta-analysis of longitudinal studies. Psychological Bulletin. Advance online publication. doi: 10.1037/a0028931

I first met Albert Ellis, the founder of Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT), about 35 years ago. Soon after I became an Associate Fellow and a Supervisor with the Albert Ellis Institute in New York City, and was a died-in-the-wool devotee for decades.

Al was open to all of us adding or subtracting a variety of techniques, whether meditation, homeopathy, yoga philosophy, or anything else, as he had already incorporated disparate ideas from areas as diverse as Buddhism and behaviorism. He wanted each therapist to put his or her own stamp on their ways of working, although I believe he assumed we would all keep the REBT skeleton beneath whatever robes we draped it in.

Rigid, dogmatic thinking was not the coin of his realm. In fact, he loved to engage in lively discussions of all therapeutic techniques and was happy to incorporate anything he believed would help shift a client to becoming more unconditionally self-accepting.

Of course, like any parent, he was proud and delighted when his baby, REBT (the precursor of cognitive behavioral therapy [CBT]), would be “proven” to be effective in alleviating depression, anxiety, anger issues, or anything else, as it was with 40-plus years’ worth of studies.

This plethora of evidence-based practice studies that have lauded the effects of REBT and CBT is what led to the Swedish government’s decision to invest heavily in training clinicians to provide CBT to people with depression and anxiety and spend no money on training or treatment in other modalities. Naturally, the Swedish government was a bit shocked when a recent study showed that training therapists in and treating clients with CBT had little or no effect.

In response to these findings, Scott D. Miller, Ph.D. wrote: “The widespread adoption of the method has had no effect whatsoever on the outcome of people disabled by depression and anxiety.  Moreover, a significant number of people who were not disabled at the time they were treated with CBT became disabled.”

Apparently, this has not deterred the American Psychological Association from resurrecting its plan to draft and promulgate a series of guidelines pushing specific treatments for different mental health issues.

Dr. Miller and his colleagues at the International Center for Clinical Excellence have analyzed many studies showing little difference between treatment approaches in terms of outcome. They argue that all approaches work almost as well, and efforts to target specific treatments for each psychiatric diagnosis are not an effective use of time and money.

Dr. Miller recently talked about what works in behavioral health and recommended shifting the focus to designing client-tailored services rather than spending so much energy on examining specific treatment models and techniques. Meanwhile, Sweden has decided to end the exclusive use of CBT for the treatment of anxiety and depression, realizing that people need to have therapy choices.

As a holistic psychotherapist for almost 40 years, I think it is obvious when treatment is working: people self-report feeling better. They engage in life more fully, sleep better, take better care of themselves, and have more satisfying relationships and more meaningful life experiences.

As much as it can be wonderfully useful to study psychological modalities, theories, and philosophies, at the end of the day it all boils down to whether the person has been helped or not. Using evidence-based practice studies as a Procrustean bed will only cause pain and prolong suffering, just as the original one tried to stretch or shrink people to fit its specifications.

Source:
Miller, S. D. (May 13, 2012). Revolution in Swedish mental health practice: The cognitive behavioral therapy monopoly gives way. Retrieved from http://www.scottdmiller.com/?q=node%2F160&goback=%2Egde_53475_member_125725759

Related articles:
What is CBT?
Deep Breathing and Guided Imagery
When Someone Really Listens, We Heal

Depression can be challenging. If you have experienced it, then you know that the most basic tasks can become excruciating and leave you feeling apathetic and drained of your willpower. Simple tasks like getting out of bed, doing the laundry, and playing with your children may be daunting. While talk therapy and medications may be helpful, they are not the only solutions to relieving symptoms. This is where art therapy comes in. Art therapy has become an effective treatment in supporting, releasing, and integrating the symptoms of depression by supporting you in exploring depression via the senses. Although art might seem less conventional, it can be just as effective as talk therapy because it utilizes the whole body experience and not just the intellect.

[fat_widget_depression_right]

When Words Do Not Speak

It can be difficult to open up to a complete stranger about your deepest and darkest emotions. Sometimes, we are taught to suppress our emotions and put on a blank face, even when experiencing inner turmoil. In art therapy, words are not always necessary. A mere lump of clay or a blank canvas can be far less threatening than giving voice to painful feelings, words, or images. The simple act of a scribble on paper can likely bring light to darkness, ignite conversation, or be a release for a depressing thought. Because something cannot be heard by the human ear does not mean that nothing is being said or revealed. Art therapy supports our process when words are not enough.

The Capacity to Feel Again

In addition to creating a communication bridge between you and your therapist, art therapy can also help you come to terms with what you are actually feeling. Perhaps you have felt numb or distanced and “incapable” of feeling when depressed. Creating art is at the heart of expression and emotion, supporting your capacity to feel again. Once you have created and externalized a part of yourself as something concrete and tangible, it is easier to acknowledge that such an emotion existed in the first place. By creating, you give yourself permission and voice to that which is difficult to speak. You might feel a sense of relief or a movement of your depression once you have transferred it onto your canvas.

Creating One’s Own Happiness

Research shows that when we observe something that we believe to be beautiful, the neurotransmitter dopamine—located in one of our pleasure centers in the brain—is released. Interestingly, the brain activity observed when we look at art is actually comparable to the brain activity representing love! It’s nice to know that in addition to having created your own art, positive feelings increase.

Research proves art therapy is a beneficial method of treating depression across a wide spectrum of personalities. Many even discover a newfound passion for art and are surprised at the talent that emerges once their emotions are channeled into their artwork. Only in this unique field are therapists performing what is considered by traditional psychoanalysts to be the hardest of tasks: getting those with depression to proactively express, manage, and overcome their symptoms … with the end result being something truly beautiful.

References:

1. Study shows art may help with depression. (2012, June 6). Retrieved from http://www.arttherapyblog.com/mental-health/study-shows-art-may-help-with-depression/#.T9dlRdUth30
2. Bar-Sela, G. (2007, Nov. 16). Art therapy improved depression and influenced fatigue levels in cancer patients on chemotherapy. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17351987
3. Holm, M. (2011, Aug. 11). Art therapy for depression. Retrieved from http://www.naturaltherapypages.com.au/article/art_therapy_for_depression
4. Riley, S. (2001, July). Art therapy with adolescents. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1071468
5. Vann, M. (2012, April 4). 8 Unconventional ways to ease depression. Retrieved from http://www.everydayhealth.com/depression-pictures/unconventional-ways-to-ease-depression.aspx#/slide-3

When assessing a patient for major depressive disorder (MDD) and choosing the most appropriate course of treatment, personality type is a major consideration. Research has demonstrated that people with high levels of neuroticism and/or low levels of extraversion often respond less well to treatment and have higher relapse rates. Briefly, neuroticism is a personality trait that includes a tendency toward negative emotions and emotional instability. Extraversion, on the other hand, describes a tendency toward positive feelings, including but not limited to higher levels of socialization and self-confidence. A recent study published in the Archives of General Psychiatry examined the links between personality type, cognitive therapy, and the antidepressant medication Paxil (paroxetine).

In multiple studies of the drug Paxil, participants who showed significant improvement in their depression also reported greater feelings of confidence and liveliness. The authors of these studies generally describe these personality changes as effects of the overall improving mood of the patients. A more recent study ponders whether selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRI) medications, Paxil in this case, do in fact work to change personality states resulting in a lessening of depressive symptoms. The study was broken into three groups: a placebo group, a therapy group, and a group receiving Paxil. Depression and personality ratings were gathered from each participant at regular intervals throughout the 16-week study.

As many previous studies have shown, even people receiving placebo showed noteworthy improvement in their depression. However, the personality trait scores underlined a potentially significant fact. Neuroticism and extraversion were both relatively unchanged in the placebo group, while those receiving Paxil or cognitive therapy showed improvement in both of these key areas. This suggests that Paxil may work to alter personality traits on the molecular level. Cognitive therapy also led to decreased neuroticism and increased extraversion, but the reasons for these changes are not as clear. What is clear is that these personality changes predict a better long-term outcome for patients and a lower chance of relapse.

The lesson from this research is that clinicians should be mindful of specific personality traits when treating an individual with MDD. Paxil, and possibly all of the SSRI medications, may work to improve depression on a more fundamental level than anyone realized. The data has always been there, in a sense, but perhaps the interpretation was lacking. As researchers unlock the mysterious relationship between moods and chemical neurotransmitters, more specifically targeted drugs will be developed. Furthermore, as the early warning signs of depression—neuroticism, low extraversion—are better identified, interventions will be possible to prevent this debilitating mental health condition before it occurs.

References

1. Depression (major depression) – MayoClinic.com. (n.d.). Mayo Clinic. Retrieved March 8, 2012, from http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/depression/DS00175
2. Tang, T.Z., DeRubeis, R.J., Hollon, S.D., Amsterdam, J., Shelton, R., & Schalet, B. (2009). A placebo-controlled test of the effects of paroxetine and cognitive therapy on personality risk factors in depression. Archives of General Psychiatry, 66, (12), 1322-1330.

Never underestimate the power of talking with someone who really listens.

Our culture doesn’t encourage people to talk about their emotional pain. Our culture teaches people to suppress their feelings. People tell each other not to “whine” about problems or not to “dwell” on them. People are told to “get over it” and to “be strong,” meaning “don’t feel anything—and if you do, don’t talk about it or show it.”

One example of this is when only certain emotions are deemed “appropriate.” Anger, especially for men, is more acceptable than sadness or anything vulnerable. So, for many men, emotions like sadness, loneliness, disappointment, anxiety, guilt, and shame get funneled into expressions that look like anger. Unhealthy coping mechanisms—such as using alcohol, other substances, or addictive activities—are taken up in order to push the genuine feelings down. These provide some temporary relief but, ultimately, undermine a person’s strength, health, and functionality.

Most people, when they feel upset, benefit by talking to someone who listens patiently, nonjudgmentally, empathically, and who shows that he/she understands at a deep level. There is something basic in the way human beings react when receiving this simple, but skillful, response to talking about their emotional pain.

Depression is no different from any other emotional pain, in this sense. [fat_widget_right]If everyone who felt depressed was comfortable talking about it to a good listener, we would have far fewer depressed people—possibly even fewer people on antidepressants.

Recently, a psychiatrist who was treating a friend of mine said that few people truly have a chemical imbalance causing their depression. Maybe this is why some research shows that antidepressants work about as well as placebos. Maybe the placebo works because the patients get some caring human contact before taking the pill. Human contact goes hand-in-hand with talking. We all need to see people smile at us, be warm toward us, perhaps even touch us in a friendly, appropriate way. Warm, caring human contact is essential for us to live and thrive.

Ideally, we would all have this in our lives without having to pay someone to get it. We would all have friends, relatives, spiritual leaders, mentors, teachers, or healers around to listen and care when we are upset. Yet our culture no longer supports this basic need. We are too busy. Many of us come from families who have abused us, or from whom we are separated. We often live alone, or have only our immediate family around. We are not connected to a church or community where this kind of talking may have been more available in the past. Instead we put value on the rational, over the emotional, to the extreme. As a result, many people end up trying to hide their tears and vulnerability, thus creating more alienation and isolation. Ironically, suppressing our feelings and being deprived of warm contact actually makes us more susceptible to depression, making people think they have even more to hide.

So if you are feeling depressed or in emotional pain, try to find someone you can talk to—someone who will listen deeply and without judgement. Talk to him/her about everything that’s seriously bothering you, and keep talking until you feel relief (even if you have to go through several people to have as much time talking as you need). If there’s no one in your life like this, and you don’t think you can find anyone, find a good therapist. It will help to do your talking with a highly trained, skilled, and naturally intuitive professional. You owe it to yourself to do whatever it takes to prevent depression, or deeper depression. It’s really so simple (though not always easy), yet so important.

Adults who have survived childhood abuse are more likely to experience mental health problems than those who were not abused during their youth. Depression, anxiety, panic, posttraumatic stress, eating and food issues, and substance abuse are just some of the psychological conditions that these survivors face. Another consequence of childhood abuse is diminished physical health. Research has shown that negative psychological well-being decreases physical health and can lead to serious health problems, including hypertension and heart disease. But few studies have examined how specific types of childhood abuse affect physical health directly.

To address this gap in research, Cathy Spatz Widom, Ph.D., of the Psychology Department at John Jay College at the City University of New York recently conducted a study that sought to determine the link between three individual types of abuse and later physical health problems. Widom analyzed data from adults who had been abused prior to their 12th birthday. The average age of the participants was 41. Each participant underwent a complete physical examination and blood test in adulthood. Based on documented reports of the abuse, Widom compared how sexual abuse, neglect/maltreatment, and physical abuse in childhood affected the participants’ health in adulthood.

She found that the adults who had experienced neglect and maltreatment had poorer oral and visual health as well as impaired airflow and increased risk for diabetes. The adult survivors of sexual abuse were more likely than the other participants to develop oral health issues and hepatitis C. They also had higher rates of HIV and malnutrition. Those who had survived physical abuse were also at increased risk for malnutrition and diabetes. Although some of these conditions could be attributed to maladaptive coping techniques, such as smoking, drug or alcohol use, and poor nutrition, the findings clearly show that adults who have survived childhood abuse are still at increased risk for significant physical health problems. Widom believes that these findings have strong clinical implications. She said, “Understanding the mechanisms that place abused and neglected children at higher risk for these adult physical health outcomes will help focus these efforts.”

Reference:
Widom, C. S., Czaja, S. J., Bentley, T., Johnson, M. S. (2012). A prospective investigation of physical health outcomes in abused and neglected children: New findings from a 30-year follow-up. American Journal of Public Health, 102.6, 1135-1144.

Most classes of antidepressant medications, including the selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), are thought to require 2 or more weeks of use before therapeutic effects become noticeable. The consumer guidelines for a drug like Celexa (citalopram) clearly advise patients not to expect immediate benefits but to continue taking their medication as prescribed. However, a recent study has cast doubt on the notion that SSRIs really take weeks to build up to therapeutic levels. If the results are confirmed with subsequent experiments, then our understanding of these medications will be greatly enhanced. Observing the neurochemical mechanism behind specific SSRIs will naturally lead to more beneficial prescribing patterns and better patient outcomes.

In a study of the SSRI Celexa, 26 participants were given either a single dose of the drug or a dose of placebo, a harmless sugar pill. None of the participants had depression, a fact which allowed researchers to study specific physiologic responses without interference. Three hours later, participants were shown images of frightened faces while brain activity in their amygdala was measured via magnetic resonance imaging. Psychiatrists have theorized that hyperactivity in the amygdala is a measurable effect of depression that places the individual in a constant state of heightened anxiety. In the single-dose Celexa study, participants given medication showed a muted response in their amygdala when viewing frightened or anxious faces. Researchers observed a spike in amygdala activity in those who received placebo. These findings demonstrate that potentially therapeutic effects begin as quickly as a few hours after the first dose of Celexa, and by extension any SSRI. Interestingly, none of the participants reported either a change in mood or unusual side effects. The study authors theorize that the action on the amygdala has both immediate benefits on an unconscious level and longer term effects on anxiety.

Depression is often described as a constellation of symptoms and effects. Because of its many manifestations, the disease is a long way from being fully understood. There is currently no fool-proof, one-size-fits-all treatment for depression. Research on antidepressant medications like Celexa helps us identify what’s happening in the depressed brain. Armed with that knowledge, we can tailor more effective medications in the future. The study under discussion, for example, highlights the possibility that Celexa’s beneficial effects begin with the amygdala, the brain’s primitive fear center. More importantly, these effects begin almost immediately, contrary to previous assumptions.

References
Murphy, S., Norbury, R., O’Sullivan, U., Cowen, P., Harmer, C. (2009). Effect of a single dose of citalopram on amygdala response to emotional faces. British Journal of Psychiatry, 194(6), 535-540.

Several research studies have investigated the possibility that the antidepressant medication Luvox (fluvoxamine) could be an effective therapy for alcoholism. Most of the studies involved rats, but researchers consider the results applicable to humans as well. Despite the enormous public health burden of alcoholism, treatments for the disease are still well behind the curve. The rate of successful remission and abstinence is low, regardless of treatment plan. Comorbid disorders such as severe depression or anxiety further complicate matters and increase the likelihood of eventual relapse. Adequate treatment usually requires a combination of approaches—cognitive therapy for treatment of mood disorders, pharmaceuticals for managing alcohol withdrawal and cravings, and ongoing counseling to reduce the chances of a return to drinking.

A study with lab rats revealed that Luvox potentially reduces the response to food, or alcohol, or both, depending upon the experimental conditions. The goal of the study was to determine if Luvox might reduce the craving for alcohol, but the results were not conclusive in that regard. Significant changes in stimulus response were recorded even at very low doses of the medication. When food and alcohol were presented together, rats treated with Luvox responded less to food but maintained the same consumption of alcohol. However, presenting one stimulus and then another in sequence had differential effects. Responses to the second stimulus, regardless of whether it was food or alcohol, were decreased in the presence of Luvox. The temptation has always been to link all reward-seeking behaviors into a single category. Studies like the above, however, demonstrate that food-seeking and drug- or alcohol-seeking are biologically distinct events. The intricate and complex workings of such behaviors are still largely mysterious.

Due to uncertainties in its effectiveness for the purpose, Luvox is unlikely to play a role in the reduction of alcohol cravings. The rat studies returned mixed or confusing results, and no human trials have demonstrated a predictable, reliable mechanism of action. At this time,  there  isn’t enough evidence to conclude that the medication can successfully manage alcohol cravings. However, Luvox is effective in treating the depression and anxiety that accompany the recovery process after alcoholism. As a safe and effective mood stabilizer, Luvox reduces the chances of relapse. When Luvox is combined with cognitive therapy, a person recovering from alcohol addiction has a high likelihood of achieving a healthy outcome.

References

1. PubMed Health [Internet]. (n.d.). Bethesda (MD): National Library of Medicine. Fluvoxamine. Retrieved April 4, 2012, from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmedhealth/PMH0000955/
2. Ginsburg, B. C., Lamb, R. J. (2006). Fluvoxamine effects on concurrent ethanol- and food-maintained behaviors. Experimental and Clinical Psychopharmacology, 14(4), 483-492.