Rising Above Violence Against Women: An Interview with Paul Kivel

A silhouette of a man looks out at the sunrise on the summit of a hill. Domestic violence continues year-round. Some research estimates that every nine seconds a woman is abused. More than 85% of domestic violence is directed toward women, and women are much more likely to incur serious injuries or be killed during domestic violence incidents. Men are between 400% and 800% more likely to kill their partners than women.

Ninety-two percent of women rank ending rape and domestic violence as top political priorities. Domestic violence is typically treated as a women’s issue, but for violence prevention and social justice activist Paul Kivel, targeting women is an incomplete solution. Kivel sees violence against women as a men’s issue. Educating and mobilizing men, Kivel argues, plays a critical role in ending the cycle of abuse.

Kivel, who has authored several books about ending violence, co-founded the Oakland Men’s Project in 1979 to help men combat violence. Although the Oakland Men’s Project no longer exists in its official capacity, its founders and participants continue to work to end violence. In the 1970s he became involved with the women’s movement. His experience made it clear to him that men, perpetrators of a disproportionate number of murders, assaults, and rapes, had an important role to play in stopping abuse. He has been conducting anti-violence seminars for men of all ages, including those with histories of abusing women, for 30 years. In an interview with GoodTherapy.org, he discussed the role men can play in ending violence.

Gender-Role Conditioning

Gender-role conditioning plays an important role in the development of children. Adults can rattle off a laundry list of traits associated with boys and girls, and children pick up these associations strikingly early. Kivel emphasizes that male gender-role conditioning plays a pivotal role in violence in adolescence and adulthood. In his seminars, he frequently uses an “Act Like a Man” box to itemize the traits associated with men: dominance, being in control, winning at all costs, athleticism, sex, aggression, and being tough top the list. These traits become a central part of men’s identities and render them likely to commit violent acts, particularly when their masculinity is threatened. From an early age, society teaches men to react to stress and helplessness with aggression and violence.

Compounding this problem is the fact that men often don’t learn skills commonly associated with femininity, such as nurturing, compassion, and gentleness. This gives them fewer options for creative problem solving in relationships and further contributes to the cycle of violence.

In his seminars, Kivel aims to help men understand that aggression doesn’t have to be a central part of masculinity. Men can be strong and assertive while being nurturing and gentle, and men who understand the harm traditional gender roles have done are better able to avoid repeating the harm. Fathers who teach these lessons to their sons are less likely to raise their boys to become violent men.

Why Men Should Be Involved in Antiviolence Activism

Kivel believes that men have a moral obligation to work to end violence. They also have a personal interest in the subject because many men’s lives are ripped apart by violence. While outreach to women is necessary, stopping abuse at its source is the true recipe for sustainable change.

Kivel emphasizes that men’s violence doesn’t just harm women. It’s also exceedingly damaging to men, hinders their intimate relationships, reduces their ability to be close to their partners, and removes men’s ability to be nurturers. Men also are frequently the victims of other men’s violence. A violent culture provides a very limited range of acceptable behaviors for men. By actively working to end violence, men make it safer for all adults and young people in the community.

What Men Can Do

Most men are not abusers. Indeed, many men are dedicated to finding solutions to stop the destructive violence that tears families and communities apart, and others are intimately aware of the problematic role aggression and anger plays in their lives. These men, however, may be unsure of what to do. Kivel offers four steps that men who are serious about ending violence can take:

  1. Examine your own behavior. Men must work to ignore dangerous messages and examine problematic assumptions of power and control. Kivel pointed out that it’s nearly impossible to work to end violence until you’ve addressed your own socialization and problematic behaviors. For many men, this means accepting that simply being male grants them a certain degree of privilege. You can’t fix what you don’t acknowledge, and acknowledging the power imbalance between men and women is a meaningful first step.
  2. Challenge other men. Most men have encountered sexist, derogatory, and degrading locker-room talk, jokes, and insinuations about women. Kivel emphasized that these behaviors aren’t harmless. They contribute to a culture of violence against women. Challenging other men is not easy, especially because the men who are confronted often respond by questioning the masculinity of the challenger. For this reason, men need to be secure in their masculinity and comprehend that degrading behavior toward women is not a sign of strength. Men who realize that violence does not have to be a part of the male identity will be empowered to confront violent or sexist behavior when they see it—even among friends and family.
  3. Talk to your sons. All young men need role models and mentors, and men should reach out to family members, friends, and boys in their communities. By educating young men about alternatives to traditional aggressive masculinity and by modeling caring behavior, confidence, and emotional intelligence, you can help redefine “masculinity” and move away from the violence forced upon young men. In modeling ethical behavior, men will shape the minds and inclinations of the next generation.
  4. Work for better education and public policy. Legislation that treats domestic violence as the serious offense it is should be a top priority, Kivel says. Kivel also emphasizes the value of transformative justice, which encourages systemic change through education and rehabilitation. He explains that most male abusers who enter the criminal justice system are there for charges unrelated to their abuse. For this reason, the justice system needs to provide education that works to undermine systemic violence and teach men meaningful coping skills. It is equally important to provide education to young men to prevent abuse before it begins rather than punishing it after it happens.

Kivel’s recommendations aren’t just utopian fantasies of an idealistic man. His strategies for ending violence have worked to stop violence at its source for decades, and the Oakland Men’s Project has been successful at educating men, helping victims, and stopping the cycle of abuse. Similar organizations have sprung up all over the country. You can find an organization in your area by clicking here.

If Kivel could change one myth about violence, in general, and violence against women in particular, he said he would end the idea that men are innately, unavoidably violent. If that were true, anti-violence strategies wouldn’t work. Kivel’s work demonstrates that education can overcome years of conditioning. Men are not incurably flawed and recognition of this can empower men to stop violence.

References:

  1. About domestic violence. (n.d.). Foundling. Retrieved from http://www.foundling.org/dvlinks.html
  2. Kivel, P. (1992). Men’s work: How to stop the violence that tears our lives apart. Center City, MN: Hazelden.
  3. Renzetti, C. M., Edleson, J. L., & Bergen, R. K. (2010). Sourcebook on violence against women. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
  4. Westbrook, L. (2009, December). Gendered violence fact sheet [PDF]. Sociologists for Women in Society.
  5. Women eight times more likely to be killed in domestic disputes than men. (2012, April 17). Global BC. Retrieved from http://www.globaltvbc.com/women%20eight%20times%20more%20likely%20to%20be%20killed%20in%20domestic%20disputes%20than%20men/6442622787/story.html

© Copyright 2012 GoodTherapy.org. All rights reserved.

The preceding article was solely written by the author named above. Any views and opinions expressed are not necessarily shared by GoodTherapy.org. Questions or concerns about the preceding article can be directed to the author or posted as a comment below.

  • 6 comments
  • Leave a Comment
  • steven

    steven

    November 1st, 2012 at 2:35 PM

    it snot enough to say end the violence against women.what men need to do is demonstrate it,demonstrate their support.and the best way to do it is to not only not involve in domestic violence but also allow women to express themselves freely and in short move towards being open minded.a lot of domestic violence stems from the superiority feelings in men and when that is controlled this condition of domestic violence will get under control too.

  • Levi

    Levi

    November 2nd, 2012 at 4:12 AM

    We live in a culture that presumes that men are still in control..But I grew uo in a home that was very much the opposite, my mom always wore the pants in the family and was the one who taught me right from wrong. She gave me the tools that I needed to be a success but more importantly to be a good man. I think that she succeeded.

  • Jose Pablo

    Jose Pablo

    November 2nd, 2012 at 10:25 PM

    I don´t know where you get those statistics that claim that 85% of DV is directed towards women. The most reliable sources describe a much more symmetric pattern of perpetration and victimhood between men and women.

    An article that describes how men can help prevent DV is commendable, indeed. But given that most of the aggression in a couple is bidirectional, it would also be appropriate and compeling to dedicate an article to scientific findings about DV and what are the areas that both partners should address in order to prevent this serious problem.

    A serious and truly preventive approach cannot overlook female perpetration.

  • katy

    katy

    November 2nd, 2012 at 11:43 PM

    it’s not enough to discuss with the victims about violence against women,the group that contributes the most perpetrators(men) needs to be made a part of the exercise if it is to be successful.violence against women cannot stop without the involvement of men,period.

    good points made here with regard to how men can control such behavior in them and others.i all follow this and some common sense then a vast majority of the violence today will go away quite easily.

  • Duncan Crickett

    Duncan Crickett

    November 16th, 2012 at 1:45 AM

    As a 20 year old male, I find the white ribbon campaigns ads to be both offensive and pathetic. What they have done is made the assumption that the entire male gender is to blame for the behaviour of a small minority. If there was an ad campaign saying “Are you mother enough to stop violence against your own children?”, there would be complaints of sexism left right and center, despite official figures released by the police earlier this year showing that children are more at risk from their own mothers than any other group. This is because society and feminism have made it OK to put the blame onto men, despite the overwhelming majority of men find domestic violence abhorrent.

    Yes, domestic violence exists. Yes, it is a serious problem, and many people, mostly women (if the above figures are accurate) are hurt and killed by it. But don’t blame the entire male gender and make it all our problem. Violence against women isn’t the only bad thing. We have violence against men, and children too. As a society we need to come together and say that ALL of these things are unnacceptable, not simply shift the blame. To do so will create more resentment and problems than it will fix.

    Rant over.

  • Domestic Violence New Jersey

    Domestic Violence New Jersey

    August 20th, 2013 at 2:03 AM

    Domestic violence is a big curse for the society and there must be hard and fast rule to fix it.

Leave a Comment

By commenting you acknowledge acceptance of GoodTherapy.org's Terms and Conditions of Use.

* Indicates required field.

 

Advanced Search

Search Our Blog

   
GoodTherapy.org is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, diagnosis, medical treatment, or therapy. Always seek the advice of your physician or qualified mental health provider with any questions you may have regarding any mental health symptom or medical condition. Never disregard professional psychological or medical advice nor delay in seeking professional advice or treatment because of something you have read on GoodTherapy.org.