Grief Decisions and Ongoing Depression

grief-decisionSometimes, when people experience a terrible loss, especially if it’s a traumatic loss, they make a life-changing decision in the middle of the intense emotional pain. Such decisions are made often without even realizing it or remembering it. This decision can potentially affect them for the rest of their lives, and can cause chronic depression. People do this to cope with the loss.

In the shock of loss, people focus very narrowly on getting through each excruciating moment. Thoughts like, “I’ll never love again,”or, “I’ll never trust again,” seem at the time like ways to avoid ever feeling this unbearable pain again. When people are free of acute pain and are able to let other experiences guide them, they usually do not make these kinds of grief-driven decisions. The following examples illustrate two situations where grief-driven decisions originated and their consequences several years after.

Grief from Childhood
Chris, an 8 year-old girl, is being raised by a father who beats her when he is drunk and frustrated with his life. He also blames her for causing him to do it. Her mother is afraid of him, so she does not stop him. Her grandmother lives next door. Sometimes Chris can escape her father and run to her grandmother’s house. Most of the time, her father does not follow her. In this time, he gets a chance to cool down and sober up before she returns. If he does follow her, her grandmother protects and defends her until he gives up.

When her grandmother dies, Chris is overwhelmed with grief and fear. Whether in actual words or not, she says to herself, “I’ll never be safe again.” Within a few days, she has her first panic attack. She has frightening dreams about being chased. No one is helping her with her feelings of fear, sadness, and anger about her family.

The decision sticks, and she comes to adamantly believe that she is not safe in the world. She is afraid to date when during her teen years. She is afraid to leave home to go to college. She fears making her own life out in the world. Ironically, the danger was never out in the world: it was at home.

At 20, her life consists of living with her parents on a powder keg of intense, unresolved anger and sadness she never considers. She goes out to school, but is afraid to trust men or even get close to women. She is lonely, feels helpless to change anything for the better, still has panic attacks and sees no point to living.

Of course how her parents treated her caused a great deal of her pain. But before her grandmother died, she had a sense that she had the power to keep herself safe and that safety existed in the world. Losing those two beliefs when she lost her only source for them caused her to make this decision that she would never be safe. That decision led to her creating a life that did not feel worth living.

If she realized she made that decision, and gained new perspective, she could see that the danger came from her father when she was a child, helpless to protect herself. A change in perspective on past trauma often takes some Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprogramming (EMDR) trauma therapy.

After her realization, it would be more apparent that she now has many resources she lacked back then. She can get away from her father, and she can make herself safe. The fear is about what happened in the past and about a situation she will never be in again, father than about her present or future. Traumatic grief-driven decisions stay locked in, as if time had never passed and nothing had changed.

Loss in Adult Life
Another example would be a woman in her 30s whose beloved husband dies. In her grief, she decides, somewhat unconsciously, that she will never love again. Smaller decisions go with it, establishing that she will not risk being heartbroken again and that she will honor their love by never loving anyone else. Again, she may forget or not even realize she made this decision.

Five years later, her life may be going well in other ways, but she is lonely. No one she dates ever turns out to be a serious partner. She may believe she will never find anyone, and become depressed about being alone the rest of her life.

She doesn’t know how to understand why she hasn’t been able to find a relationship, unless it’s because she’s unlovable. This conclusion depresses her further. She has not realized that she’s been rejecting every man she meets because the decision she made at the peak of her grief is lodged inside. Her decision keeps her from seriously considering anyone as a partner.

If she can see that she made these decisions when she lost her husband, she can reconsider whether she wants to stay committed to them, or would rather make different decisions at this point in her life. If the loss was traumatic, she may need some therapy to get the message of the new decision to the traumatized part of her brain. But once it gets there, she will be free to love again.

Healing Involves Making New Decisions
If you have had a major loss any time in your life, try going back in your mind to what you might have decided in your intense grief. These decisions can be uncovered and re-made. Then we can begin to change the direction our lives are going to match the new decision.

© Copyright 2010 by Cynthia W. Lubow, MS, MFT. All Rights Reserved. Permission to publish granted to

The preceding article was solely written by the author named above. Any views and opinions expressed are not necessarily shared by Questions or concerns about the preceding article can be directed to the author or posted as a comment below.

  • Leave a Comment
  • eliza

    October 7th, 2010 at 11:46 AM

    such thoughts have come to my mind quite a few times…when i am in a difficult situation…i have vowed never to do a certain thing again…but i have done the same thing without facing the same negative result and it is a good thing…and i thought that the vow i made to myself bent over time…but now after having read this i am a little scared and even confused a little to be honest…is it that the vowed is still lodged in my mind and that i cannot do the same things with full potential…?


    October 7th, 2010 at 7:15 PM

    Yes, eliza. That is exactly the message that this post is trying to convey. You may think that its all over and that you have put it all behind. But it stays in some corner of your mind and has an influence on you in a way that may not be obvious but surely exists.

  • Kayla

    October 8th, 2010 at 4:39 AM

    never a good idea to make life changing decisions when dealing with grief and loss- that is definitely not going to be a good time to process your emotions in the healthiest of ways.

  • Cynthia Lubow, MFT

    October 11th, 2010 at 11:44 PM

    I’m sorry; I didn’t mean to imply that anytime anyone makes a vow to themselves it affects them for the rest of their lives. If the decision is not made in the context of a trauma, it can be re-evaluated as circumstances change. When something traumatic occurs, it seems that information gets stored in a way that is different than usual. Information around a traumatic experience gets stored in an encapsulated way–cut off from other areas of the brain. It is stored without an awareness of time passing, and without the benefit of information that comes after the trauma. So if someone getting raped thinks “I’m going to die” during the rape, that thought gets locked in time, uninfluenced by information outside of that moment. Naturally after it was all over, we would expect to realize we weren’t in that immediate danger anymore. But if the thought “I’m going to die” is stored as a memory cut off from the realization that time has passed and the rapist is in jail, etc, we continue to feel panicked long after the danger is over.

    So if you’ve had traumatic experiences or losses, and you feel stuck in your life in a way that doesn’t seem to make sense, it’s worth investigating whether or not there may be a connection. If what you do and think and feel make sense, given your circumstances, and you don’t feel like your struggling against yourself for mysterious reasons, or you’ve seen yourself alter vows you made in the past to fit current circumstances, then this is probably not an issue for you.

  • Wanda Shepherd

    January 25th, 2011 at 9:10 AM

    My youngest son was developementally handicapped. Two weeks after he turned 40, he hung himself. Said nobody loved him. He was called ugly and retarded. He
    wasn’t retarded. He was smarter than I was. Could take a computer apart and make it work, then put it back together. He was made fun of on the internet. He
    said he wished he was dead. He’d always clung to me,
    but the family doesn’t understand why I haven’t been ablel to cope. I pray all day. Cry all night. And it seems to be getting worse instead of better. I’m on medication for depression but…….well, I’d probably be worse without it.
    We’re on SS and my son had collected things all his life. We boxed a lot of it up, to take to the flea market, and it was stolen. That seemed to be the
    final straw for me. I fight against suicide every day.
    I wonder when I’ll loose the fight.
    Thanks, I just needed to talk………………

  • kelly

    May 26th, 2011 at 3:28 PM

    Hi Wanda, My life has been a series of ups and downs.Real highs and low lows. I have a son, not handicapped, so I cannot relate to that, but the depression…oh yes. They give me medication and it seemed to make me worse, just think how your son would feel if one day he woke up and you were just gone! I believe he would be traumatized. Compared to you, I feel selfish, I cry all night for many reasons, and I always feel sad, and I cannot shake it. Nothing goes right,I have lost my way and dont know the way back.There are alot of things to cope with in this life, I wish I could go with the positive thinking crap, but that doesnt work either. In either situation the most important person is our sons… always. Try and feel better, I’ll pray for you, and thanx, I needed to talk to. kelly

Leave a Comment

By commenting you acknowledge acceptance of's Terms and Conditions of Use.

* Indicates required field.

GoodTherapy uses cookies to personalize content and ads to provide better services for our users and to analyze our traffic. By continuing to use this site you consent to our cookies.