Avoidance in Trauma Survivors: An Interview with Robert T. Muller

Photo of Robert MullerThose who have endured trauma experience unique challenges in coping with life after the fact. It may feel as though no one understands the anxiety, depression, nightmares, flashbacks, and other issues characteristic of posttraumatic stress.

Because of this, people who have experienced trauma tend to avoid intimacy and closeness in relationships. While it may be difficult for a partner, family member, or friend to offer the necessary support, there are professionals who are very familiar with what it takes to heal and recover from a traumatic incident.

Clinical psychologist Robert T. Muller, PhD, wrote a book on the subject: Trauma and the Avoidant Client: Attachment-Based Strategies for Healing, which was published in 2010. As part of our continuing education web conference series, GoodTherapy.org was fortunate enough to have Dr. Muller present on “Engaging the Traumatized Client Who Avoids Closeness and Vulnerability” in April of 2011.

Recently, Dr. Muller, who is also an associate professor at York University in Toronto, Canada, shared some of his insights with us in a written interview on roughly the same topic. Specifically, he reveals the common traits associated with those who have developed avoidance-based coping strategies in response to trauma, and he discusses how to help these individuals in therapy.

GoodTherapy.org (GT): What do you think is the biggest obstacle in overcoming trauma?

Robert T. Muller (RTM): The biggest obstacle is fear. Fear of getting hurt … yet again. Fear that people who seem trustworthy aren’t. It requires great fortitude to open up and take interpersonal risks when you were hurt by the people you trusted most.

GT: Why do people with a history of trauma often have trouble in interpersonal relationships?

RTM: A client of mine once told me, “You live what you know.” When what you know is betrayal, that’s what you live.

GT: What does attachment have to do with trauma?

RTM: Humans naturally seek closeness. Trauma takes away what is most natural, making simple interpersonal contact scary and complicated.

GT: Are trauma survivors more resistant to therapy than other people who seek counseling?

RTM: No, they’re not more resistant. And they can be rewarding to work with, even inspiring. But it’s not easy. For therapists, the trick is being open to difficult painful truths: The world is often unjust, [and] good people suffer. We can’t rescue our clients from their painful histories, but we can help them gain understanding and empathy for themselves, rather than judgment and self-reproach.

GT: What kinds of therapeutic strategies work best with trauma survivors?

RTM: Relationship, relationship, relationship. With survivors of interpersonal trauma, change happens through the here-and-now relationship between client and therapist. As a therapeutic alliance develops, as the client starts to feel a connection to the clinician, this feels scary, and the person struggles as they do in all relationships: They don’t know how to trust. They may push the therapist away (because that’s easier than worrying they’ll be abandoned); they may even criticize the clinician or become angry at times. How the therapist weathers these moments in the relationship makes all the difference. If the clinician becomes defensive or critical, it’s game over. But if the therapist sees this as an opportunity, an important moment in their relationship to help the client work through the conflict between them, that’s where change really happens. The person truly learns how the world of relationships can be nonexploitative and rewarding.

GT: How can therapists engage avoidant trauma survivors in therapy?

RTM: Even clients who avoid closeness and painful feelings are in the therapist’s office for a reason. Find that reason. What’s in it for them to change? Working with them can be hard, because they’re masters at pushing people away. The trick is seeing their distancing maneuvers for what they are: fear of closeness.

GT: What do you hope therapists will take away from your new book, Trauma and the Avoidant Client: Attachment-Based Strategies for Healing?

RTM: Up to now, avoidant trauma survivors have been ignored by the field of mental health; that’s a missed opportunity. As a way of avoiding closeness, they drink, become workaholics, get addicted, overdo food or exercise, and so on. But those strategies don’t work, at least not in the long run. Ultimately, they need to experience the emotions that go along with closeness; to feel loss, sadness, pain, and vulnerability without becoming terrified of losing control or falling apart. The best tool I know is the therapeutic relationship. My book focuses on how to help clients like these by skillfully using the therapeutic relationship as a vehicle for change. What they fear is closeness, but underlying that fear is a painful longing, a yearning to feel loved. And at the end of the day, therapy is about learning how to allow yourself that gift.

© Copyright 2013 GoodTherapy.org. All rights reserved.

The preceding article was solely written by the author named above. Any views and opinions expressed are not necessarily shared by GoodTherapy.org. Questions or concerns about the preceding article can be directed to the author or posted as a comment below.

  • 7 comments
  • Leave a Comment
  • Nancy T

    Nancy T

    December 19th, 2013 at 3:48 AM

    It must be very rewarding to work with someone over a period of time and then look at how far they have come by working out their thoughts and feelings with you.

  • Jenna

    Jenna

    December 19th, 2013 at 2:16 PM

    Luckily I have never experienced something so traumatic or horrendous in my life that I have felt the need to hide or avoid it. I don’t like to face the small conflicts in my life though so I know that for these survivors, facing these things which have happened to them and caused them much pain must be so frightening to deal with and confront. I commend anyone who is able to work through these sorts of things.

  • Patricia Szymanski Clark

    Patricia Szymanski Clark

    December 19th, 2013 at 9:01 PM

    We’ve all learnt to avoid at some level, and we all have our own personal habits in how we do this – it’s just that people who have been traumatised have had to become very clever at it. It takes a long time to get used to the idea that it’s possible to not have to constantly be hyper sensitive and alert; it needs to be a gradual process anyway. And yes, it’s all about learning this through relationship.

  • therapydoc

    therapydoc

    December 30th, 2013 at 7:11 PM

    Always interesting, once burned twice shy, or something like that. I’m linking over. Good luck with the book!

  • Tami Barkley

    Tami Barkley

    August 16th, 2014 at 7:17 PM

    What is the best therapy regime for a child? My granddaughter (8) and step daughter were kidnapped by my granddaughters father. They were taken int Mexico an held for a year. My step daughter has not dealt with the trauma she buried it. But my granddaughter has horrible abandonment issues and isolates, even though it happened when she was 2 1/2 she fears that her father will come back and shoot her, her mother and her brother. I just don’t want to enable the behavior of fear, but I don’t want to be insincere either. My step daughter is not on top of therapy for either of them and I just want to help.

  • Lisa

    Lisa

    October 31st, 2014 at 1:39 PM

    I wish I lnew a way to check (or test) my reality for objectivity as I had a therapist I never felt seen nor understood by and whose clinical opinion was offensive and in a more recent opinion of a PsyD (as opposed to the first therapist, an MFT) was grossly inaccurate. I’d sought the PsyD to continue treatment for the condition I never fully believed I had, as diagnosed by the MFT. Whenever I disagreed with her, she would say, verbatim, “that’s exactly what someone with ____ would say.” At this point I am terrified of therapists because that one is still a voice of confusion and second guessing or doubt which I live with day to day and although friends and family noticed my immediate and consistent improvement upon finally terminating her (despite her insistance against termination), I am hell bent on sorting out the objective truth because im willing to be wrong if that means getting better AS LONG AS that means recieving the appropriate treatment in order to do so. The misdiagnosing MFT had no approach I was aware of, did not include my wishes in treatment (in general), did not actually see the real me, and whatever treatment modality she considered herself to administer didn’t help, may have been gas lighting in the end, and was essentially an abysmal failure. I know that in my mind, she never saw me and I think that is probably all I need to know – that’s MY objective reality – yet I still feel a compulsion to prove the validity of my reality, basically to prove my existence as it is instead of as she wanted it to be. And perhaps that’s ths problem…. Hmmm…

  • Pauline

    Pauline

    March 5th, 2016 at 3:58 PM

    Avoidance is something that is somewhat of an eventuality I find when supporting trauma survivors. I have found Robert’s book to be an asset in my therapy, and I have often looked back in the book for new insights to help with different patients. Also, I believe that it is crucial to see that Dr. Muller is a scholar void of pragmatic sense, for he operates his own psychotherapy practice in Toronto! psychotherapytoronto.ca However, one problem I have with Robert’s answers in this interview is the last answer where he says “As a way of avoiding closeness, they drink, become workaholics, get addicted, overdo food or exercise…”. I think it is peculiar that he suggests addiction as anything different than the other activities in his list, as over eating, working, etc. are, at least in my understanding, synonymous.

Leave a Comment

By commenting you acknowledge acceptance of GoodTherapy.org's Terms and Conditions of Use.

* Indicates required field.

GoodTherapy uses cookies to personalize content and ads to provide better services for our users and to analyze our traffic. By continuing to use this site you consent to our cookies.