Why Does Mr. Wrong Feel Like Mr. Right?
September 1st, 2011
By Tina Gilbertson, MA, Self-Esteem Topic Expert Contributor
Click here to contact Tina and/or see her GoodTherapy.org Profile
Please note: This article does NOT apply in cases of violence or abuse. There can be nothing “right” about such a relationship.
Feels so bad it’s good
He doesn’t usually call when he says he will.
He’s not great at expressing affection – especially in public.
He doesn’t seem all that interested in introducing you to his friends.
You can’t get him out of your mind. He’s catnip!
Why does it sometimes feel so right to be with Mr. Wrong?
If his behavior is driving you nuts, and that pattern doesn’t change and it doesn’t lead to a breakup, it must be because – are you ready? – his indifference and/or lack of communication and/or infidelity is basically okay with you. Sure, it hurts like heck and no, of course you don’t deserve to be treated that way! But on some level it must be okay with you, or you wouldn’t stick around for it.
You are not in any way responsible for his behavior. Nor do you deserve to be treated poorly. You are not to blame for how you’re treated. You are, however, responsible for understanding how and why his bad behavior is allowed to continue. There’s usually more to it than “because I love him” can convey.
Low Self-Esteem, Low Expectations
For better or worse, we’re most comfortable when our partner’s attitude toward us matches our own attitude toward ourselves. In other words, we’re drawn to people who treat us the way we secretly believe we deserve to be treated. So if you’re putting up with behavior you don’t like, ask yourself whether it’s because on some level, it feels right. Not good, mind you, but right.
Have you ever been in the shower when the water suddenly turned cold? Didn’t you jump out of the way to avoid the sudden chill? You weren’t expecting or wanting a cold shower; you wanted a nice, warm, comfortable shower. Your expectations were upset when the temperature dropped, and you extracted yourself until the water felt right again.
Even though you dread being hurt in your relationship, is it what you’ve come to expect?
When you were a kid, how often did you feel criticized, rejected or neglected? To the extent that you felt those things, they will feel normal to you. That doesn’t mean they’re easy to take; they didn’t feel good then, and they don’t feel good now. What they are, maybe, is familiar.
We all find comfort in familiar patterns, even when they leave us chilled to the bone.
If only he’d change!
What would it be like to be with someone who always called when he said he would? If he were reliable, affectionate and committed to your relationship, would you still belong together? Or is it possible that if he really did change, he wouldn’t feel like the right partner for you anymore?
Think about this: What would be required of you if he were different?
If you’re with Mr. Wrong and can’t seem to let him go, keep these pointers in mind:
1. Realize that the pain is probably deeper than this relationship
Assuming your partner’s behavior is reflecting your expectations, it’s likely that you’re working through painful feelings that originated long before you met him. Those feelings have nowhere to go but through your heart and out. Feeling is healing. Therefore…
2. Focus on your feelings, not his behavior
When we feel hurt, we often try to soothe ourselves by focusing on the situation, or other person. We think and think and think and think. This helps distract us from feeling. ‘If he would just behave differently…’ ‘If I could only make him understand …’ ‘If I knew for sure he loved me …’
But our feelings remain: we feel lonely, rejected, abandoned, miserable. How do you concentrate on your feelings rather than his behavior? Try this…
3. Express your feelings to a compassionate listener
Write down how you feel, or express it to someone who can hear your feelings without trying to solve the problem. This might mean entering therapy, where you can explore your feelings with the help of a professional.
Remember, a good therapist will concentrate on helping you understand your feelings rather than telling you what to do. Friends and family will tell you what to do – why pay for that?
By focusing on what you’re bringing to the relationship – your lowered expectations and painful feelings from long ago – you can break the cycle of hoping he’ll change, and take your own power back. When something begins to shift in you, you can be sure there will be a resulting shift in your relationship.
© Copyright 2011 by Tina Gilbertson, MA, LPC, therapist in Portland, OR. All Rights Reserved.

8 Comments | Click here to leave a comment.





Comments
There are some relationships and feelings that can’t be explained but we have all been there. We know that he drives us crazy and all we ever really think about is how great he would be if oinly he would just change a few things about him. But think about it. If there is more about that person that you would like to change than there are things that you honestly like about him, then there is a mistake brewing in the air.
I dont understand how some people survive with such individuals-a friend of mine puts up with her boyfriend’s antics.sometimes he is just so very rude to her but she continues.dont know how to actually talk to her about this though..
Hi Tina! Love could not be defined. I think that we like the whole mystery in love.It keeps us exited, a feeling which moves mountains.Great post!
Hi Brad,
It is so hard to watch a friend put up with poor behavior in a relationship!
If you want to help your friend, treat her with respect and be a great listener if she opens up to you.
The more she feels respected by you, the more she’ll notice and be bothered by disrespect from others – including her boyfriend.
Mr Wrongs are always way more exciting than Mr Rights! I guess that speaks volumes about most of the men in my life right?
@Sabrina- yeah and that frustrates the crap out of us good guys! We try to do the right thing and be what we think women want and you guys always want what we are not.
@George Ugg, I know! And I feel so bad, but there is know way we can help it. It’s kinda like why good girls like bad boys, they’re just way more exciting. A guy who doesn’t treat you as well as you think you should be is more fun. You actively have to try to get him to pay attention to you and there is something about this that drives women, me included, nuts! I feel like a guy does when he is chasing a girl who is playing hard to get. The only difference is for the MR. Wrong guys it isn’t an elaborate act, it’s “4 reel”. Mr. Rights are great at first but then slowly turn dull. It’s the same thing with them you always know what to expect, where as Mr.Wrongs keep you on your toes with questions like “Will he remember my birthday?”.
I love your writing! You’re very good! Ilissa Banhazl, Marriage and Family Therapy, Glendora, CA
Leave a Reply
By commenting you acknowledge acceptance of GoodTherapy.org's Terms and Conditions of Use.