Love Is Not Enough: Important Considerations Before MarriageJuly 20, 2012 • By Deb Schwarz Hirschhorn, PhD, Relationships and Marriage Topic Expert Contributor
Jack had a spring in his step as he headed for home. It was 2 AM, but the night had flown by. He was so in love. Karen was beautiful, inside and out. And, miracle of miracles, she loved him too! She had told him that. Tonight, she made it clear. It wasn’t just attraction; it was love! They would spend a lifetime together. His head was full of his dreams and plans as he headed home. He couldn’t wait to see her again and texted her right there in the middle of the street at 2 AM. “I luv u; g’nite,” he wrote. “I luv u 2” came back the immediate reply.
Jack and Karen had been dating for six months. They were not teenagers; they were mature adults with responsible jobs. They’d had their share of weird, annoying, or just plain wrong relationships. This one was different and they both said so to any friend that would care to listen. They were seeing each other often; at least three times a week. They’d had all the deep and heavy talks.
They were not living together and neither one wanted to. Perhaps you’d call them romantics; perhaps their religious values just happened to be in alignment, but that was a decision they both agreed on. What they did seem to want was to get married.
The question is: Have they done their due diligence?
Their what? They are not hiring employees! What are you talking about, Dr. Deb?
So let me ask you: In which instance do you have more to lose—making a wrong hire or choosing the wrong mate? See, I thought you’d understand. In fact, if we were wise, we’d all do the due diligence before falling head over heels for someone because it’s an awful lot harder to untangle yourself when you’re in love. In fact, once you’re smitten, you will argue with your best instincts; you will ignore the advice of friends; you will deny what you see; and you will forget the arithmetic you learned in third grade (as in adding up 2 + 2).
Allow me to suggest to you four broad areas to take a good look at before getting married:
1) Does she or he treat you right?
If he or she ignores you when you’re talking, goes out with others, forgets to invite you to social or family events, isn’t polite, finds fault, wants things his or her own way all the time, doesn’t ask your opinion, blames, criticizes, is sarcastic, flirts with others, forgets your birthday, or a host of other things that you can easily imagine, then he or she may not be treating you right.
I was just talking to a mom about her daughter who is recently engaged. Her daughter’s fiancé expected this mom to pay for the entire wedding, but he wanted only the most expensive hall and caterer. I was surprised. I thought men weren’t into that so much. No, she told me, this one was. “And how does your daughter feel about it?” was my key question. “She doesn’t agree with him,” this mother came back. “She’s a frugal person. She earns well but wants to save much more than he does.”
Now I was surprised again. How could this couple get this far without having ironed this out? Doesn’t this young man want to please her? The mom explained that her daughter feels she should compromise to make her man happy. Well, that’s lovely. I agree in theory. But what is he donating to the cause? Compromise is a two-way street. If one person always gives in, that person will feel resentful over time.
Marriage is all about giving. That’s first base. It’s not about you; it’s about the other person. No chance of a home run if you can’t get to first base.
Besides love, marriage is a place where laundry and groceries and childcare get done. In order to elevate what could feel like drudgery to something pleasant, maybe even fun, there’s got to be a feeling of teamwork. Well before that ring is given, you’ve got to find out just what kind of a team you will be when it comes to finances, parenting, cleaning, and errands. This may be the central most critical part of marriage.
2) Do you like his or her family?
Assuming the worst, there are only two ways to handle it: Your partner makes a clean break with the family or you end the relationship. There is no third choice. The clean break is financial, social, psychological, and perhaps geographical. Your partner must be a very strong person to be able to do that. The problem with clingy parents whose child will never marry anyone good enough for them is that they have brainwashed their child into thinking that they really do know best.
This is very clever. When their adult child believes parents have their best interests at heart, the child will not question their motives. The child will not be able to break free.
Someone I know was in a relationship that raised eyebrows. I suggested he speak to his girlfriend’s sister’s husband to get the lay of the land about what it’s like to be in that family. After all, that guy will become his brother-in-law eventually, so he’s a good person to ask: an outsider-insider.
A family could seem very lovely and accepting but still not want to let go of their child. At the last minute, they can pull the rug out. How do you prepare?
The answer is: Don’t ignore the tip of the iceberg. In other words, never, ever say, “Oh, that only happened one time.” No! Nothing is out of character. Whatever you observe is always part of a bigger pattern. So if your girlfriend’s parents stop a date, or weigh in negatively on your job, your character, your behavior (provided these are all sterling), or throw monkey wrenches into your relationship in any way, be forewarned.
Here’s something that actually happened to Jack. Karen’s parents decided to include her on their vacation. Karen is 26 and certainly doesn’t need to go with her parents. However, they were going to a resort and insisted that it would be such a nice bonding experience to have her for a week, especially before she gets married. This just happened to overlap Jack’s two weeks of vacation time, and he had been looking forward to spending it with Karen. Well, at least he’d have the second week, he thought. Then Karen texted him from the hotel to say that they were extending their stay another week.
Do you see the iceberg? When it comes to your partner’s family, your partner had better have your back.
3) Do you have a lot in common?
Opposites do attract, but research shows that for a marriage to work out, the best foundation is to have religion, work ethic, family values, and other biggies more or less on the same page.
Make a list of what’s important to you and then tag a weight on each item from 1 to 10. Then compare with your partner.
4) Are you married for 30 years or are you just dating?
The rules are completely different if you are already married. Elsewhere on this site and on my own site and in my book I’ve talked extensively about turning around a marriage that is in pain. I’ve talked about healing, reconnecting spiritually, reigniting the passion, and starting over with your own spouse, even when there’s been verbal abuse.
This is because you have created a shared life together; you may even have children together. In the 5, 10, 20, or 30 years or more that have intervened, there is some kind of bond that must be respected. Statistics back me up: The one who files for divorce tends to end up more depressed as time goes on than the one who received the papers.
But when you are just dating, I don’t care whether it is a year or two, you don’t have that same shared life. You only have lost a little time, but nothing more. You think you have invested your heart, but you will see as you go forward that the investment was a drop in a bucket compared to divorce after a long-term marriage.
So, to reiterate my rules: When it’s a shared life, give the benefit of the doubt in trying to get along. When it’s a relatively new relationship, follow the tip-of-the-iceberg rule and run the other way if these four elements are not in place.
The preceding article was solely written by the author named above. Any views and opinions expressed are not necessarily shared by GoodTherapy.org. Questions or concerns about the preceding article can be directed to the author or posted as a comment below.
LeggettJuly 20th, 2012 at 11:14 AM
This really hit home for me because I have always thought that it was enough to just be in love, but after reading this I realize that no, there are hundreds of other things that have to fall into place before you can know deep in your heart that this is the right person for you. Yes there has to be checmistry and you have to be attracted to the person, but do you really like and respect who she is on the inside? Are you comfortable merging your families together and can you say without a doubt that you can ,love her family like they are your own? Do you have things in common that you actually like talking to one another about? I think that so many times we get so hung up on the thought that this is the perfect person for you that we forget to dig a little deeper and discover whether or not this is really the truth. I think that it takes being honest with yourself, your partner, and going beyond the surface to get to the real person inside. And if you are willing to do that kind of work, then it is likely that this is a person you could spend the rest of your life with.
G. H. Ellis, MDJuly 20th, 2012 at 11:40 AM
It sounds as if the daughter’s fiance may have a pronounced father complex!
cooper kJuly 20th, 2012 at 3:48 PM
It’s hard when you think that you have this instantaneous attraction to someone and you start thinking that this could be it, this could be the one. You kind of forget all of the other stuff that you should be looking for too, it just all, boils down what you are feeling right now. And then when you get to really know this person and you realize, hey, we really don’t have that much in common, it’s still hard to let it go when in so many other ways it feels so right.
HEATHJuly 20th, 2012 at 9:21 PM
Wonderful post! This is something that everybody looking to settle down with their partner should read. Marriages are breaking down at a never-seen-before rate and the reason is that people are not able to live together, people find that they are not compatible and other things that most often could have been prevented. An assessment such as the one you have suggested would be a good measure of how to proceed further when you have decided to convert a relationship into marriage.
DeanneJuly 21st, 2012 at 4:44 AM
Let me present this in a slightly different way.
When there is love, real love, then I happen to think that IS enough. But what you have to understand is that to me, REAL love already encompasses the fact that you do have something in common, you do love the other partner’s family, and you do enjoy spending time with each other.
Without those things, I can’t homestly say that I think you are really in love anyway.
jake tJuly 22nd, 2012 at 5:41 AM
what happened to love conquers all?
Heather MJuly 23rd, 2012 at 4:29 AM
I have to admit that I am one of those people who got married without thinking about the consequences that marrying into his family would bring. I thought that no matter what he would always choose me, that I could win out over the rest of them. I was very wrong about that. Most of them were always in our business and he always took their side and advice over anything that I had to say. Needless to say, we didn’t make it because I couldn’t stand always feeling like I was second fiddle, as I was. He never saw that, he thought that he always put me first, but I was never made to feel that way at all.
mary catherineJuly 24th, 2012 at 4:34 AM
Seems so dismal to say that love isn’t enough.
RonaMarch 29th, 2016 at 11:34 AM
I’ve never been on this website. I was doing some research in considerations for marriage, found this, and thought “GoodTherapy.org? Must be a good one.” Halfway through the article, I couldn’t agree less. The key points all have merit, but for a therapist to openly endorse such all-or-nothing, black-and-white thinking is rather alarming.
“Marriage is all about giving. That’s first base. It’s not about you; it’s about the other person. No chance of a home run if you can’t get to first base.” This is considering the future groom’s desire to have an expensive wedding at the future bride’s mother’s expense. Not cool, I get it. But if marriage is all about giving, and respecting the other person’s wishes, isn’t the future bride accepting that the exact act of giving? I’m not saying who’s right or wrong. I’m definitely not rooting for the future groom to have it his way. But this statement seems to very one-sided.
Then, “[a]ssuming the worst, there are only two ways to handle it: Your partner makes a clean break with the family or you end the relationship. There is no third choice.” I had to stop there. I mean, you’re kidding, right? Is this personal projection? Or is this sound and kind advice to anyone who’s looking to get married?
Lastly, “[b]ut when you are just dating, I don’t care whether it is a year or two, you don’t have that same shared life. You only have lost a little time, but nothing more.” Yes, having dated a year or two might not compare to a shared life of 30 years with children. But to get to a shared life of 30 years, you have to have that first year or two. It’s about the experience you create together. Perhaps during that year or two you’ve undergone a family tragedy, and that special someone was there for you the entire time. Or maybe you shared a lot in common, but cannot agree or accept on big values. Please do not dismiss people’s experiences together or apart, for however long; moments count, because it is the moments that build into a lifetime.
Leave a Comment
By commenting you acknowledge acceptance of GoodTherapy.org's Terms and Conditions of Use.
Search Our Blog
- The Other Side: That’s so true and she indeed complained that I’d become needy (given that I felt nothing coming from her I was trying...
- Sarah: Hello, Melody – thank you for writing. “Culture shock” is often a pretty good metaphor for what you’re describing:...
- Laurie Leinwand: Kendra, I love the feeling of crossing things off a list as well! Glad you have a winning technique. :)
- Bonnie D: I am so sorry that you are going through this. I have been dealing with it also, my husband did 5his while he was suffering from...
- Myra D: I thought that my husband and i had all of these things and somehow all of them put together still wasn’t enough to save our...