Stop Trying to Impress Your Clients: Dr. Pamela Garcy on What Makes a Good Therapist

For many therapists, the first session with a new client can feel like an audition, with an unspoken pressure to make a good impression and demonstrate their expertise.

Am I asking the right questions? Am I demonstrating enough expertise? Does this client feel comfortable with me? Will they want to return?

Dr. Pamela Garcy, a Dallas-based psychologist, GoodTherapy member, and practitioner trained in cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and rational emotive behavior therapy (REBT), remembers that feeling.

“I used to go into my initial sessions trying to be impressive, and this would freak myself out. I would go in there and clench up, which does not help the rapport building at all.”

This pressure to perform is not limited to therapists just starting their careers. A qualitative study of eight therapists with at least a decade of clinical practice found that all eight questioned whether they were making the right decisions in sessions, while seven questioned how effectively they were helping their clients.

Even years of clinical experience, it seems, do not always quiet the question: Am I doing enough?

For Dr. Garcy, the turning point came when she stopped focusing on how she was performing and started focusing on the person she was there to help. Her experience brought a shift in perspective. Being a good therapist became less about demonstrating everything she knew and more about understanding the person sitting across from her.

In this GoodTherapy Member Spotlight Interview, she reflects on what she learned from the pioneers of CBT and REBT, how her approach to building therapeutic relationships has evolved, the daily reader she wrote for therapists called The Present Coach, and why sometimes the most valuable thing a therapist can do is slow down.

Therapist Directory

GoodTherapy Starts with Feeling Understood

Finding the right therapist is about more than credentials. It's about connecting with someone who listens, understands your needs, and makes you feel heard.
Find a Therapist on GoodTherapy

Watch Our Conversation With Dr. Pamela Garcy

Watch on YouTube

In this interview

Q: You had the opportunity to learn directly from the founders of CBT and REBT. What drew you toward these approaches?

Dr. Garcy: “I looked at cognitive behavioral therapy and REBT and thought these were great approaches because the research really supports that they help. I wanted something research-based, something that had evidence of really helping people.

Getting to learn from the founders was exciting because I was a beginner. I came in with a very open mind, ready to receive and learn.”

One experience with REBT founder Dr. Albert Ellis left a lasting impression on Dr. Garcy. While attending his lecture as an intern, she missed his book signing because she was returning a patient’s call. When she approached him afterward, he refused.

Dr. Garcy: “He said, ‘Because you procrastinated. I hope you always remember this lesson.’ I was shocked, but it stuck with me. It taught me to think twice about putting things off and to recognize when it’s time to take action.”

Q: Looking back at your early years in practice, what was the most important lesson you learned about being a good therapist?

Dr. Garcy: “One of the most powerful lessons that I’ve learned is to focus on the service versus your own self-consciousness. I used to go into my initial sessions trying to be impressive, and I would freak myself out. I would go in there and clench up, which does not help the rapport building at all. You have skills that you might not really realize you have. But not only that, just your presence can be healing if you’re willing to slow down, be open, and listen for a while. Get to know the person. Don’t just jump in and start doing stuff. Really take your time.”

Her advice speaks to a common tension in clinical work: therapists need knowledge, preparation, and sound judgment, but the pressure to demonstrate those qualities can sometimes shift their attention away from the client.

Q: What helps a therapist build rapport with a new client, particularly during those first few sessions?

Dr. Garcy: “We feel so rushed in our culture. Just slow down, take your time, and get to know this human being who’s on the other end. That’s going to help you determine what’s best for them.

Maybe you need another session to ask more questions. Maybe you need to do some testing or arrange testing with another therapist who does it.

Recognize that your job is to be of service. If you’re the person who is meant to help this other person across from you, they’re going to want to hire you. And if it’s not a good fit, do you really want to work with that person if it’s not a good fit? We can take the pressure off ourselves and just work on one conversation at a time.”

For therapists building their practice, this is an important distinction. An initial consultation is not simply an opportunity to convince someone to become a client. It is also an opportunity to understand their needs, evaluate whether your expertise is appropriate, and determine whether the relationship is a suitable fit.

Q: Is there a distinctive perspective that has shaped your approach towards your clients?

Dr. Garcy: “I tend to see people as whole coming in, and that has evolved over time. There is this idea that people come into therapy thinking there’s something wrong with them, and that’s why they need therapy.

I really don’t see it that way.

I see it as people needing to learn some new ways, some new approaches to help themselves in their lives, and that they already are whole.”

She illustrates this belief through an analogy she sometimes shares with clients.

Dr. Garcy: “If we went to a nursery and looked through the window at newborn babies, we wouldn’t stand there and hold the same judgments that we hold about ourselves or other people. We wouldn’t say, ‘That one isn’t good enough, that one isn’t smart enough, that one isn’t pretty enough.’

We would just see these newborn babies and think, ‘Wow, what a miracle of life.’ That’s how we started. We aren’t broken. We come in whole.”

For Dr. Garcy, approaching clients without the assumption that they are fundamentally defective and need to be fixed helps establish a more open and accepting starting point for therapeutic work.

Q: Much of your work focuses on helping people examine their thinking. How can therapists help clients move from self-judgment toward greater self-understanding?

Dr. Garcy: “One limiting belief I hear all the time, and one I used to have myself, is ‘I shouldn’t be feeling this way’ or ‘I shouldn’t be reacting this way.’

It’s a demand upon ourselves that we’re not supposed to feel how we feel or react the way we’re reacting. I’m not saying we always pick the best response. But if we realize our response isn’t working for us, we can work on giving ourselves more choices and developing new skills.”

She encourages people to become curious about what happens between an experience and their emotional response.

an experiencea thought, or maybe multiple thoughtstheir emotional response

Dr. Garcy: “Very often, what’s in the middle is a thought, or maybe multiple thoughts. Part of the therapy process is slowing the whole thing down and looking at what ran through your mind right before you felt that way. If we have a response that’s catching our attention, let’s get curious about it, explore it, and figure out what’s going on. Let’s understand ourselves versus shaming ourselves for having a very human response.”

This approach reflects a practical application of cognitive therapy: helping clients recognize and examine the thoughts influencing their emotional experiences, without adding another layer of shame for experiencing those emotions.

Q: You speak about the importance of slowing down and being present. How do you practice that yourself as a therapist?

Dr. Garcy: “One of the things I’ve found helpful is getting present before going into a conversation with another person.

I do this with my sessions. I take a pause before I go from one session to the next. I don’t just run in. I ground and center myself. I’ve found this so helpful, both as a concept and as a practice.”

This idea is also central to her book, The Present Coach, a daily reader offering short practices for cultivating presence. Originally written with helping professionals in mind, Dr. Garcy sees its relevance extending to anyone who wants to become more intentional in their relationships.

Her approach offers a useful reminder for therapists managing demanding schedules: being present with one client also involves giving yourself space to transition from the previous session.

What Makes a Good Therapist? Dr. Garcy’s Takeaway

For Dr. Garcy, being a good therapist is not about having every answer ready, using every technique perfectly, or making an impressive first impression. It is about bringing your knowledge and clinical skills into a relationship where the client feels heard, respected, and understood.

That takes preparation, ethical judgment, curiosity, and sometimes the willingness to slow down rather than immediately intervene.

For therapists who are just starting out—or experienced clinicians who occasionally feel the pressure to do more—her advice is worth remembering:

“One of the most powerful lessons that I’ve learned is to focus on the service versus your own self-consciousness.”

Perhaps the question to carry into your next session is not, “How can I demonstrate that I’m a good therapist?” But rather, “What does this person need from me right now?”

About Dr. Pamela Garcy

Dr. Pamela Garcy is a licensed psychologist, author, and GoodTherapy member based in Dallas, Texas. Her professional background includes training with influential figures in cognitive behavioral therapy and rational emotive behavior therapy, including Dr. Albert Ellis (Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy), Drs. Aaron and Judith Beck (Cognitive Therapy), Dr. Donald Meichenbaum (Cognitive Behavior Modification), and Dr. David Burns (TEAM Cognitive Behavior Therapy).

Her work emphasizes evidence-informed approaches, thoughtful self-examination, and helping individuals develop new ways of responding to life’s challenges.

Explore Dr. Pamela Garcy’s GoodTherapy Profile

Reference

Thériault, A., & Gazzola, N. (2005). Feelings of inadequacy, insecurity, and incompetence among experienced therapists. Counselling and Psychotherapy Research, 5(1), 11–18. https://doi.org/10.1080/14733140512331343840

Garcy, PD (2026). The Present Coach: Your Companion Guide to Traversing Life with Clients. Maurice Bassett Publishing.