Study Suggests that Sometimes Hope can Hurt

November 10th, 2009  |  

A GoodTherapy.org News Summary

In many situations involving medical news and prognoses that aren’t especially favorable, physicians and other health professionals may feel inclined to find some measure of hope to give their clients, in an effort to soften the blow or to provide some comfort. Clients themselves may also suspect that taking on a hopeful perspective can yield a more positive result for mental health and overall well-being; after all, people are reminded to have faith and preserve their hope throughout their lives, and may learn many valuable lessons by doing so. Yet in some instances, especially those involving difficult news or events, a state of hopelessness may be more beneficial than a focus on the potential of the issue to improve. In support of this idea, a study recently carried out at the University of Michigan has examined colostomy clients to determine whether hope-–or hopelessness–is better for well-being.

The study examined two groups of those who had recently undergone colostomies, having their colons removed and required to have bowel movements in pouches laying outside of the body. Some of the participants were candidates for a reversal surgery following a period of recovery, and were told that there was a chance of returning to normal bowel function. Other clients, however, were unable to have reversal surgery for any number of reasons, and so had no hope of ever returning to their previous state. The researchers found that those who had no hope for reversal reported being far happier and experienced greater well-being than those focused on the possibility of reversal at a later point.

The results point to the benefits of closure, suggest the researchers, and may help dictate how clients, whether facing physical or psychological issues, are treated by health professionals.

© Copyright 2009 by http://www.GoodTherapy.org Therapist San Antonio Bureau - All Rights Reserved.

  • Join GoodTherapy.org - For Therapist Only
  • JUSTIN November 10th, 2009 at 10:11 AM #1

    This is pretty confusing… I don’t quite understand how hopelessness would help a person who has to realize of something very negative about himself.

  • Henrigues November 10th, 2009 at 10:33 AM #2

    Sometimes giving false hope is more damaging than breaking the news at once… it is better to say out the truth than to beat around the bush. the person will anyway get to know of it eventually…

  • nathan November 10th, 2009 at 3:49 PM #3

    I have to agree with what Henrigues said… anyway the person will eventually know what problem he/she actually has and will have to face it…there is no reason to first say stuff that is around the actual idea and then indirectly say it… I feel it does more harm than good…thats because it gives the person more anxiousness and probably more reason to panic!

Leave a Reply

By commenting on this blog you acknowledge acceptance of this Blog's
Terms and Conditions of Use

* Required

Subscribe

Subscribe to RSS feed

Subscribe via Email
Email me updates to the Therapy Blog!


Subscribe Unsubscribe

Note to Self

GoodTherapy.org is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice, diagnosis, medical treatment, or psychotherapy. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified mental health provider with any questions you may have regarding any mental health symptom or medical condition. Never disregard professional psychological or medical advice nor delay in seeking professional advice or treatment because of something you have read on GoodTherapy.org. By using this site, you signify your assent to the terms and conditions contained in this Agreement. If you do not agree to all of the terms and conditions contained herein, do not use this site.

Blog Categories

Recent comments

  • Harriet: I don’t think lies are always a bad thing. If it gets you through the day and you’re doing the best you can, why beat yourself...
  • LaScala: I have another piece of advice: take contraception with you. Especially if you’re a girl. Even if you think you don’t want to...
  • Tabitha: I have a friend that is sweet to everybody. She is a very caring soul and it exasperates her husband that she can’t sometimes walk...
  • Josh: What a lot of nonsense! How much time and money did they waste on this “study”??
  • Nathaniel: Of course they think it’s not a big deal. That helps them justify behaving like animals in their own minds. Some guys even think...

Submit Articles

Find a Therapist | Explore Therapy | Workshops | Blogging Therapy | About Us | Contact | Join Us | Log in | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Sitemap

Copyright © 2007-2010 GoodTherapy.org. All Rights Reserved.