Internal Family Systems and Multicultural Couple Relationships
November 27th, 2009 |
By Mona Barbera, Ph.D., Internal Family Systems Therapy Topic Expert Contributor
Click here to contact Mona and/or see her GoodTherapy.org Profile
If you are in a multicultural marriage, you know how hard communication can be. Whether it’s about:
• in-laws – how much influence and involvement they have
• privacy – how many people are in your house on a daily basis or at special gatherings
• women’s roles
• conflict – hidden or overt ways of dealing with it
• being indirect/understated vs. being direct and expressive with requests, complaints
• accommodation to others vs. competition with them
• authority – who has it and who has to follow it
• showing affection/closeness – how much you need or show
• the individual’s needs and rights vs. the family/community
• being misunderstood or misunderstanding languages or gestures
• feeling neglected/feeling pressured
• male vs. female roles
• lack of knowledge/judgment of each other’s music, language, or culture
• loneliness/loss when you are living in the other person’s country
Multicultural relationships can be a great, rewarding adventure. Maybe you are the adventurous type, and you love contact with another culture. Or maybe you were surprised when you found yourself committed to someone from another culture. Love happens!
Internal Family Systems couples therapy can help you with your multicultural couples issues.
But here’s the catch: you need to commit to doing what’s within YOUR OWN control to make the situation better. Who is within your control? Not your mate – only you.
Are you willing to focus on your own participation? Are you ready to shift from 50% responsibility to 100% responsibility? Then read on…
But first, here are a few basic IFS terms to help you understand the model.
Your natural state is calm, connected, courageous, clear, curious, compassionate, creative, and confident. In IFS that is called Self energy. You never lose it. It’s always available to you, no matter whom you are or what happened to you in life.
Often, when we are growing up, our families or cultures judge something about us – maybe we are too lively or they think we aren’t smart enough. And sometimes our families, even though they usually try their best to love us, hurt us in some way. They might not give us all the attention we need, or siblings might be very competitive, or people might get very angry and frustrated with us. These hurt feelings are often too intense to deal with, so we wall them off. We end up thinking we don’t feel judged, hurt, or neglected because we push these feelings so far away. We are usually afraid of them, because when they do get through to us, they are often very intense. We sure don’t want to feel consumed by loneliness, hurt, anger or depression – no one would like us! In IFS, these hidden hurt feelings are called Exiles.
As we grow up, we develop habitual patterns so that we won’t be hurt. If people try to control us, maybe we will try to control them first, or we’ll just go along because it isn’t worth it to try and fight.
If we felt lonely, maybe we’ll just convince ourselves we really don’t’need people.
These habitual ways of keeping ourselves safe are called Managers in IFS. They are busy, busy, busy, all day long, trying to keep us safe. For more information see “Internal Family Systems,” by Richard Schwartz, or “Bring Yourself to Love,” by Mona Barbera.
Despite our Managers’ best efforts to keep us safe, sometimes people (especially our spouses!) get through our protective perimeter and hurt us. Then we need to do something fast to feel safe again. Maybe get angry, go off in a huff, give up, or retreat to a safe distance. IFS calls these quick reactions Firefighters, because they race out to save people from danger, just like real firefighters.
Most of the problems in couple relationships come from Firefighter reactions. We are innocently going about our day, and all of a sudden our mates do something that makes us feel intensely unloved or disrespected.
But if your reaction is intense, it’s your own. I know, the last thing on your mind is your own unworthiness, fear, or loss of control. You are totally focused on the wrongdoing of your mate.
But if you feel intensely hurt, demeaned, or sad, it’s definitely your own feeling. Your mate might have sprinkled a little salt on a wound, but that wound was there before your mate came into your life.
But remember, we’ve been pushing our intense hurt away since childhood – we turned them into Exiles, and made ourselves believe we didn’t really feel so bad. That was a good thing – it was much easier to go to school and make friends if we weren’t sad all the time.
Since our Exiles are so far away from awareness, we don’t know that we already feel hurt, demeaned or disrespected.
We think our mates caused it!
Firefighters to the rescue! We attack, punish, lecture, demean, control, or give in to our mates in an effort to make the hurt stop.
Now let’s get specific about multicultural relationships.
Your natural state is calm, connected, courageous, clear, curious, compassionate, creative, and confident – Self energy.
So if your mate from a different country or a different culture misunderstands you, you have the ability to stay present and communicate well.
But if the way you felt hurt matches your Exiles – you will have a Firefighter reaction, and their will no chance of a calm, creative solution. Firefighters don’t care about solutions – they don’t even care about your mate. They just want the pain to stop. And they think your mate caused it.
Let’s take the example of in-law involvement. Let’s say your partner’s culture includes in-laws more than yours does. At first when they stopped by without calling, when they gave opinions, when they assumed they would come with you on trips – it was fine. Then you started to get angry.
But you forgot that when you grew up, your older brothers were very controlling. They borrowed what they wanted. They sat on you if you didn’t go along. You were smaller so you couldn’t do anything.
You made yourself a little clubhouse where you could get away from it all. It was so small only one person could get in! That’s all you wanted. It was safer to be alone. You learned to occupy yourself alone. You didn’t need people.
Now with all these nice in-laws around all the time, it feels bad. You don’t know why – because you succeeded pushing those awful, out of control, scared feelings from your brothers away. They are Exiles – you don’t even know they exist anymore.
Here’s the secret: If you can own those intense feelings as your own, you will find out they are from the past. When you find your Exiles and acknowledge how bad they feel, they will relax.
Then you will have all the creativity, love, clarity, and courage you need to talk to your mate about the involvement of his or her in-laws. You’ll be able to stay calm when your mate gets defensive at first. You’ll be able to be clear when your mate doesn’t understand. Most important, you’ll be able to stay connected instead ofdistancing or getting angry.
©Copyright 2009 by Mona Barbera, Ph.D. All Rights Reserved. Permission to publish granted to GoodTherapy.org. The following article was solely written and edited by the author named above. The views and opinions expressed are not necessarily shared by GoodTherapy.org. Questions or concerns about the following article can be directed to the author or posted as a comment to this blog entry. Click here to contact Mona Barbera, Ph.D. and/or see her GoodTherapy.org Profile




















Thank you for sharing such interesting observations Mona! I myself am European and my husband is American. Our ten year relationship has been fraught with difficulties because of how differently we were raised. Life becomes easier as you develop an understanding of each others’ upbringing. We laugh now over those things rather than fight.
Heck, even the differences between being from the North and South in this country can create a chasm between a couple.I had a short term boyfriend that was from the opposite end of the country and we couldn’t find a middle ground. We were just too different.
I was in a multicultural relationship for a very long time yet my boyfreinds family never was really able to accept me. They could never see beyond the fact that I was black and they were white and in their eyes that was not something that they could ever live with on a permanent basis. They were just very closed minded and ultimately the price that was paid for that is that I lost a very dear man and a very special friend. I really do not see how people can still think this way in the 21st century but I had to learn the hard way that they do and nothing that I ever did was going to make them see things any differently.
There’s no way of knowing that if he was local whether that would have lasted longer Sugarlove. In my case we at least didn’t prolong the agony. We knew fast we were incompatible once we’d been out three times. We weren’t good together and had no spark. I thought he was exotic. It turned out he was deathly boring. I can get that from my home town boys LOL. ;)
Well… I think a multi-cultural marriage would be a very nice thing to do, as it will help us in understanding ourselves better and can even bring the two partners much closer than a same-culture couple because they have a lot of things to share and discover with each other :)
Well…multicultural marriages are something that are only going to increase with the rapid globalization and mixing of people of different backgrounds. Yes, there are bound to be problems in such a marriage but with the right amount of understanding and good communication, this problem can in fact be turned into an advantage and the marriage can be extremely successful.
Why is this such a problem for some people? What on earth are you afraid of? I for one think that you could only stand to learn new and exciting info about other cultures and that there is nothing to be scared of at all when it comes to being a part of a multicultural relationship. And I completely agree that this is only going to be more and more common as our world tends to become smaller and smaller. It is so easy to have contact with people from all over the world today, and I happen to think that that is a very good thing!
You need to have mutual respect for your partner’s background. I think that’s more important than understanding it. If you can show you respect it even when you don’t get it, that shows love. Isn’t love all about compromise and give and take? Making fun is the worst thing you could do. Make an effort instead and be loving.
No one person knows the right way of doing everything. In that position you could learn something by paying attention. How many people have the opportunity to gain an intimate and indepth knowledge of a foreign culture? Not many. Celebrate the differences. Don’t make them burdensome.
It’s easy to point the finger at your partner and not yourself when there’s trouble. Stop, look and listen. I was taught that growing up for road safety. It’s just as applicable over disagreements. Using all your senses to decide what the true problem is -— right here and right now -— works wonders and is much better than yelling.