Nutrition in Early Life Can Affect IQAugust 16, 2012 • Contributed by EmpowHER writer Rheyanne Weaver
You are what you eat, as the popular saying goes. And now a new study suggests that your diet as an infant may in fact determine how smart you will be when you grow older. The study, published in the European Journal of Epidemiology, found that infants who ate healthy foods had higher IQ scores by age 8 than those who ate less healthy foods. The study focused on diet at 6, 15, and 24 months of age. The researchers then followed up with subjects at age 8 years. A little over 7,000 children were included in the study.
The unhealthiest foods that led to an IQ of 1-2 points lower at all ages included “biscuits, chocolate, sweets, soda, [and] crisps,” according to the study abstract. Other types of food varied at different ages in how they impacted IQ scores. For example, at 6 months of age, a “breastfeeding pattern,” along with foods like “herbs, legumes, cheese, raw fruit and vegetables” at 15 and 24 months were linked to IQs about 1-2 points higher.
Foods such as “meat, cooked vegetables, [and] desserts” were found at 6 months to have a positive association with higher IQs, but this type of food style didn’t seem to have any associations with IQ at 15 and 24 months. Other types of foods seemed at first to negatively impact IQ but later appeared to increase IQ. For example, at 6 and 15 months of age, “ready-prepared baby foods” were found to negatively impact IQ to some extent, but at 24 months, “ready-to-eat foods” had a positive association with IQ.
“This study suggests that dietary patterns from 6 to 24 months may have a small but persistent effect on IQ at 8 years,” according to the study abstract.
Although lead researcher Lisa Smithers at the University of Adelaide stated in a media release that the IQ differences were not major, the study still suggests a need to put more emphasis on good nutrition at a young age.
This study is in no way isolated. Various other studies support a link between breastfeeding and IQ, as well as overall nutrition and IQ.
One 2011 study featured in a Scientific American article found that infants who were breastfed for more than 6 months had an average higher IQ of 3.8 points over infants who were bottlefed. However, the study suggests the IQ difference is not mainly due to nutrients in the milk but the closer biological interaction among infants and mothers during breastfeeding. This finding is further demonstrated by another study mentioned later in the article, where brain wave activity was recorded for bottlefed babies who fed on breast milk versus formula compared with breastfed babies. Out of the three groups, breastfed babies had different brain wave activity than both bottlefed groups, even though one bottlefed group still used breast milk.
Still more studies suggest that breastfeeding can enhance IQ. Research completed by Oxford University and Essex University “found that as little as four weeks of breastfeeding for a newborn baby has a significant effect on brain development, which persists until the child is at least 14 years old,” according to a ScienceDaily article. Researchers took into account other differences when comparing breastfed to non-breastfed children, such as mother’s age, marital status, job status, home situation, and education.
Various studies support a link between overall nutrition and IQ in children as well. For example, one study from 2011 suggests that young children who eat foods that are processed and are high in fats and sugars could have a lower IQ, whereas children who eat foods high in nutrients and vitamins tend to have a higher IQ, according to a PhysOrg article. Results seemed to show that diet was most important up until age 3 especially and that diet changes after age 3 didn’t impact IQ as much.
More research mentioned in a Mayo Clinic article links fish and omega-3 fatty acids to higher IQ in children as well. The research suggests that pregnant women with a higher intake of fish tend to have children with higher IQs, at least up until age 3. However, pregnant women also have to be aware of the mercury content in fish, because too much mercury could be harmful.
Nutrition and mental health experts have conflicting views when it comes to the newest study suggesting a link between consuming certain foods and increased IQ in infants.
Holly Stokes, a life coach and “the brain trainer,” said in an email that it’s important to take into account other factors that could have contributed to the higher IQs in the study as well. “It’s tempting to say that higher nutrition must then cause higher IQ,” Stokes said. “However, there could be other factors involved. For example, the IQ of the parents. It’s quite likely that the parents who are feeding their children better are better informed, maybe have researched on their own, and they themselves have a higher IQ than the parents who are not feeding their children as well. There is also some evidence to suggest that IQ has to do with socio-economic status as well.”
Scott Carroll, a psychiatrist with dual board certifications in adult and child and adolescent psychiatry and an assistant professor at the University of New Mexico School of Medicine, said in an email that this study brings up some important points about nutrition. “While 2 IQ points is actually within the usual standard error of most IQ tests, just the fact that you could demonstrate a statistically significant finding from rather minor dietary changes is a big deal,” Carroll said. “We certainly know that malnutrition has severe negative effects on IQ. The hard part about doing a study like this is that smarter parents often make healthier choices in food, which you have to statistically control for in this type of study.
“Statistically controlling for stuff like that often lowers the ‘effective result’ of the study,” he added. “Basically, if you took two high IQ families (IQ is highly genetic) with babies and fed them the two different diets with all other things being equal, you’d get a 2 IQ point difference on average. While that may not seem like much, as a soon to be parent (my wife is 4 months pregnant), we will be even more careful about feeding her the healthiest food possible.”
He said that since research already shows a link between a nutritious diet and good health, as well as a decrease in obesity, an increased IQ is just another benefit and does support an emphasis on certain food choices for infants. He has some suggestions about diet and lifestyle choices for parents and infants to ensure that their children have a healthy and growing IQ.
“Breastfeeding is clearly ideal for many reasons, but making sure mom is properly fed is important as well,” Carroll said. “Longer breastfeeding, up to 18 or more months even if the child does eat some solid foods, also helps. Key things for mom’s died include B vitamins, fish oil (must be mercury free since mercury is highly toxic), [and a] rich diet in terms of a variety of high quality fruits and vegetables. Limit the sugar content of their food. Personally, I strongly believe in eating organic even though the research on it is limited.”
“Other keys include having a secure attachment between the baby and primary caregiver, because insecure or disorganized attachment clearly affects the brain wiring in bad ways,” he added. “Having a stimulant-rich environment (bright colors, toys, etc.) and lots of time with parents with soothing verbal communication have also been scientifically shown to help.”
Lisa Hugh, a registered dietitian and mother of two boys under 3 years old (she breastfed both), said in an email that the IQ result alone isn’t enough to promote certain eating habits, but healthy eating has many other benefits as well.
“I don’t think a few IQ points alone is enough evidence to support one way of feeding,” Hugh said. “However, many studies (various sources and designs) indicate that healthy eating offers many benefits: brain size, vision development, acceptance of more tastes/textures, healthy body weight, better performance in school. All of these advantages together are reason to promote healthy eating.”
She has some diet suggestions for infants in order to promote higher IQs: “[Breastfeed] for as long as possible, minimize processed foods, give foods from all food groups (except in cases of allergy, illness, food sensitivities, food intolerances, cultural preferences, etc), give kids a variety of tastes/colors/textures/cups/plates/etc. to keep meals/food interesting and to expose them to different foods,” Hugh said. “Maintain a regular daily schedule as much as possible.”
“Each child/family/parent is unique,” she added. “There is no one absolute best way of feeding a child. Parents have to do what is best given their circumstances/needs.”
© Copyright 2012 by www.GoodTherapy.org San Francisco Bureau - All Rights Reserved.
BerkeleyAugust 16th, 2012 at 5:47 PM
While I do think that this article presents some very valid points, I would like to add that the homes that are providing proper nutrition to their children are generally going to be the ones to provide the most intellectual stimulation for the children as well. Don’t you think that it goes without saying that homes where nutrition is better, probably the intellect of the home is higher too? More college educated people are going to breastfeed their babies and feed them wholesome meals instead of running through the drive thru every evening for dinner. Nutrition undoubtedly offers a great deal of an advantage to those who get wholesome nutrients and vitamins and those who don’t, but you also have to look at the educational background of the parents and figure that this is making a big difference in IQ as well.
jeromeAugust 16th, 2012 at 6:41 PM
food and nutrition are certainly important aspects in one’s life.some may dismiss this as :I’m an eat to live, not live to eat” but what you eat really deserve some attention from your side!
and what we see today with so much obesity and unhealthy eating habits,imagine if those individuals had healthy eating habits as kids and adolescents.they would be less prone to consuming unhealthy foods in their adulthood and thus making so many things easier for themselves!
MATTAugust 16th, 2012 at 11:56 PM
While the critics of this finding are not wrong,the fact that there is enough proof that good food and nutrition aids good health and that kids develop a lot of their mind early on is enough to put my faith in this finding and this is something that all parents need to take a note of!
mollyAugust 17th, 2012 at 4:13 AM
Have you seen the stuff that some of these young moms buy with their WIC stamps? Some of it isn’t necessarily the best food for their kids nutritionally, that’s for sure!
Fran WAugust 17th, 2012 at 10:36 AM
It is my hope that more ob-gyns will talk to all of their patients about the important role that nutrition will play in the life of their child. It all starts with the foods that the mom consumes while she is pregnant and of course continues after the child is born. I cringe to think of the many things that I have seen people give young children, all of the sweet and sugary drinks, food loaded with little to no nutritional value, and this is only setting these children up for a lifetime of poor eating habits coupled with the added dangers of obesity and other health challenges that tend to accompany this lifestyle. More people need to advocate for healthy eating for kids as well as adults as we are facing a serious health crisis as it is due to all of the unhealthy products that so many of us choose to live on/.
way cupAugust 17th, 2012 at 11:18 AM
there is just so much that can either go right or go wrong early in a baby’s life.there is a lot of awareness on what to eat and do and what not to eat or do during the pregnancy.but not a lot of people give importance to what they do with the baby after the birth.not only food wise but also on a psychological level,not too many people discuss or are aware about such things.
AngelaAugust 17th, 2012 at 2:37 PM
Why does it feel like wny time there is widespread acceptance and support for breastfeeding, that something like that Time cover a few months back comes along to knock it back twenty years? This is one of the very best things that any mom can do for her child and yet so many choose not to because they worry about doing it in public or how it would make others feel if you did it aorund them. Who cares?!? This is your baby, it’s important, so I encourage any mom who can to at least giving breastfeeding a try with their newborns.
erik hughesAugust 18th, 2012 at 8:06 AM
It’s like this-
establish healthy eating habits when the kids are young and more than likely they will continue to eat in this way when they grow older and have more choices to make about what to eat and when
LizAugust 18th, 2012 at 10:11 AM
Just reinforces something that is known to have other benefits but a higher IQ?good to marketing the healthy practice and is a positive thing in general.so keep your eyes and ears open parents.
tyrellAugust 19th, 2012 at 5:21 AM
Then there needs to be more of a commitment from society as a whole to make healthy and nutritionally valuable foods more accessible and affordable for every person and not just the privileged few. I don’t think that most sane people choose fast food because of how good it is- I think that most of them choose it because they deem it to be quick and affordable. Don’t you think that they would choose aealthier alternatives if they were just as readily available and affordable as the golden arches for example? I do, because I think that most people regardless of age or education know that fresh fruits and vegetables are going to do far more good for us than the fast food options. But many have gotten into the belief cycle that that is not affordable for them on a daily basis so they continue to make the unhealthier choices.
Clayton packAugust 20th, 2012 at 10:52 AM
Whether the gains in IQ are small or large when you have better nutrition, I think that any gains in scores are something that has to be looked at.
I hate hearing people talk about how expensive it is to eat healthy, and that it takes too much time to prepare healthier meals, blah blah blah.
It is no more expensive to feed your family a healthy diet than it is to always prepare prepackaged foods. And really, if there is anything worth giving a little more time and effort to, wouldn’t your family be it?
LottieAugust 21st, 2012 at 8:01 AM
any news on if the IQ increases are only apparent in childhood or do they extend into adulthood as well?
Leave a Comment
By commenting you acknowledge acceptance of GoodTherapy.org's Terms and Conditions of Use.
Do you have a mental health story or experience that you wish to share? Whether your story is about therapy or psychiatry, self-help, personal healing, wellness, or a particular mental health condition or challenge, please consider contributing your written story to GoodTherapy.org!Share Today
- A: What I’m wondering is do people then attempt suicide by other means if their attempts to jump are foiled by a physical barrier
- Daniel: This could be exactly the sort of breakthrough in spinal cord injury research that people with those injuries have been seeking for a very...
- alexander: Looks good! Must be really exciting for your team to see such growth and to know that you are making such an impact on readers globally.
- Smith: This sort of makes me wonder if because you become so indoctrinated while in the military if leaving the service was actually a good idea...
- Corinne: Surely there must have been some kind of clue that he was this obsessed before the two of you got married?