How to Stop those Fights that Happen Over and Over Again
May 6th, 2009 |
Click here to contact Jennifer and/or see her GoodTherapy.org Profile
George had been very upset about the actions of an ex-friend. Susan could feel his pain and asked him if there was anything that she could do to make him feel better. George replied, “I could think of something.” Susan retorted, “I wasn’t talking about sex.” George responded, “So what’s new?” Susan, feeling criticized, said, “you don’t care about me. All you care about is sex.” George responded back, “well you asked. Next time don’t ask if you don’t care.” “Don’t worry, I won’t, Susan snarled. She walked away and they didn’t talk till the next day.
This interaction was a familiar and repetitive one for Susan and George. They had started out okay, but somehow they both misunderstood each other and wound up fighting.
Let’s replay this, except George and Susan are more conscious about their wounds. Instead of fighting, they are going to get closer and build more trust between them.
George had been very upset about the actions of an ex friend. Susan could feel his pain and asked him if there was anything that she could do to make him feel better. George replied, “I could think of something,” He was thinking about sex. Susan immediately thought to herself: “He’s upset and angry, I don’t want to have sex with somebody who is angry.” She was silent for a minute, trying to figure out what to do. A few minutes later, George said, “that would have been the perfect opportunity for you to have initiated sex, which you never do.” He was frustrated and disappointed. Susan could feel his anger. She felt hurt and she felt like he was taking the anger that he was feeling about his ex-friend and dumping it on her. They were looking at each other; it was clear something serious was occurring between them. Susan mustered up her courage and responded, “I just initiated last night.” George got still for a moment and realized that she had. He responded by saying, “yes you are right, you did. They continued to talk.
Susan “remembered” and recounted that she had grown up in a family where she had to take care of others’ needs at her own expense. “Nobody was really interested in what I needed,” she said. “And when you wanted me to make you feel better without considering how I felt, I got hurt. I am afraid to be vulnerable when somebody is angry and for me, having sex is being vulnerable. George responded, “when you didn’t move forward and make it all okay, my disappointment about always being let down came up. So many times in my childhood and other relationships, I’ve been let down. I just wanted you to make me feel better and it felt like you were failing me too.
Both George and Susan had been feeling unloved and not understood. But as they talked, they began to piece together the old stories feeding their reactions. They were able to talk it out and avoided a fight. They helped the other heal by listening and empathizing. And they both became more conscious of who they were and were gaining the ability to not allow the past to haunt them.
But how do we do this?
When we get reactive or triggered, it means we’ve opened an old can of worms. Think of each worm as an old story that is a wound around which we have unhappy feelings. These feelings lurk below the surface, ready to come up under the right circumstances. Rather than being in touch with our present reality, we relive old stories. Some of those stories make us angry, some make us sad. These stories can be like gasoline on a fire. They are lenses through which we view our lives and they distort our perceptions. We disproportionately and quickly escalate our emotional responses to what appear to be very inconsequential events. These stories need to be recognized as old wounds and told, both to each other and to ourselves, if we are going to be able to stop these repetitive patterns.
There are several tools to help us remember that we are caught up in a wound and repair it:
*The 90/10 rule. If we are upset, often it is 10% about the present situation and 90% about the past.
*Telling our story to our partner is building a relational bridge. Reacting as if we are right is blowing up the relational bridge. Remember, your partner is your friend. Treat him or her as if he or she is, and talk, don’t react or accuse.
*Find the sadness, loss or grief that is under the anger. It is hard to build a bridge when you are yelling and screaming, or withdrawing.
*To have a successful relationship, you have to be a person who can have a successful relationship. Become a person who is communicative and open. This is more important than trying to get your partner to change. If they don’t change, the relationship may end, but your power lies in you, not them.
*Accept that what is happening in the present moment demands your love and attention. The present moment is your friend. It is an opportunity to discover your emotional wounds and the wounds of your partner. It is an opportunity to start unraveling the old stories and stepping out of being driven by old wounds.
*Remember, we all have wounds. A relationship is an opportunity to repair these wounds. A relationship is a journey that allows us to create “home” both within ourselves and with another.
©Copyright 2009 by Jennifer Lehr, MA, MFT. All Rights Reserved. Permission to publish granted to GoodTherapy.org. The following article was solely written and edited by the author named above. The views and opinions expressed are not necessarily shared by GoodTherapy.org. Questions or concerns about the following article can be directed to the author or posted as a comment to this blog entry. Click here to contact Jennifer and/or see her GoodTherapy.org Profile



















11 comments so far
This sounds all too familiar and it is very hard not to respond as Susan and George did at first. There always seems to be some kind of past lying behind the way we react or respond. Very good article with lots of info.
AAhhh this article really spoke to me this morning as my husband and I continue to have the same fight over and over again about him not pitching in and doing more work around the house. I know he feels like I am in a constant state of nagging him to death to do things around here but he just never seems to get them done. Logically I know that we need to take this in another direction but I am not sure how to turn it around and get things moving in the direction that I would like for them to be. I feel like I work myself to death around here and never get any appreciation or recognition. Why can’t he do some of the same?
Wow, amazing post. Remembering the 90/10 rule will surely stop many arguments from escalating into something much bigger.
When I first read this article, it seemed to hit home. Although my husband and I rarely fight anymore, (may be because i like to keep the peace and now dwell on unnecessary things), I do remember the times how it used to be where no matter who got mad, it was always turned around on the other person and we each felt as if we were blaming the other and feelings got hurt. I try to remember not to blame and talk instead.. Sometimes hard to do when each think they are right.
This is great because I swear my house feels like the movie Groundhog Day sometimes.
It takes a very responsible and open person to realize all of the things he or she may be doing to contribute to a bad situation and causing the same things to happen over and over again. Unfortunately there are not too many of us out there who are willing or even able to objectively look at situations and determine how we may be contributing to them in a less than positive manner. Why is that? Are we all really that afraid to admit when we are wrong? I know that there are many times that I feel exactly like that and that I will fight tooth and nail to prove that I am right. But then I take a step back and wonder why I am doing that, why it is so important to always have the last word and the last laugh. I think that when we behave like this it is only going to continue to cause trouble for us in the long run and we will never get to a point where we can have everything work out for the best. We are scared that if we back down we can never again have the upper hand.
I agree with Kyle. It take me after getting over a fight, to really look back and see who was at fault. Maybe I was in the wrong, but at the time, it didn’t matter because I wanted to get my point across. I think it would help all of us if we tried to follow some of the tips here in this article.
You know, I read this and thought about a friend that I had in college. He and his girlfriend were constantly arguing about one or two small things, the same issues over and over again, and I so wish that I had seen this article or something like it back then because it never seemed to bother the two of them too much but it drove me crazy.
Yes, this really hits on how so many conflicts between partners continue on with no real resolution. The tips to break up the patterns are great ones.
My husband and I have been married for more than 20 years and are still having the same fights that we had when we were newlyweds. Hasn’t broken us up yet so I guess that is a good sign. It does get a little tiresome yes but I guess that deep down inside there is also some comfort in knowing that those are the only real issues we have. But maybe now is the time to start seriously looking for a way to resolve them!
I do think being judgemental has a lot to do with fights. “I am always right” is another.