Can Gay Families Teach Us about Gender Identity?June 18, 2010 • By Lynne Silva-Breen, MDiv, MA, LMFT, Family Therapy Topic Expert Contributor
For years in our culture, most of us have defined family in a particular way. We assume that when we say “family” we mean a group of people who are related by birth, adoption, and marriage. And when we say marriage, we have pictured the promised relationships between men and women.
But, gradually, these meanings are changing. Gays and lesbians have won the right to marry in five states, with number six, California, embroiled in a legal battle over the reversal of the 2008 state law allowing homosexual marriages. While many of us keep our eye on the legal and religious debates around this political movement regarding the right to marry, a new study, published this past week in the journal Pediatrics, has stirred up my thinking about parenting and the modeling of gender.
This study, to break a complex research process into very general statements, found that children raised in “planned lesbian families,” those families formed by partnered or single lesbian mothers prior to the birth or adoption of children, showed children whose scores on development and social behavior looked very similar to children raised by heterosexual parents. The authors expected to find this. But what they didn’t expect to find was that the children raised in lesbian homes scored higher than their straight family peers in some categories of self-esteem and confidence, were stronger students academically and were less apt to struggle with difficult behaviors like aggression and rule breaking.
It’s a remarkable set of findings that will take some time to make its way into popular thought. One of the study’s authors, Dr. Nanette Gartrell, Professor of Psychiatry at the University of California at San Francisco, has studied lesbian families for the last 24 years. She comments in an article at Time.com about why lesbian parents often raise such resilient children:
“They are very involved in their children’s lives,” she says of the lesbian parents. “And that is a great recipe for healthy outcomes for children. Being present, having good communication, being there in their schools, finding out what is going on in their schools and various aspects of the children’s lives is very, very important.”
The same research revealed a higher level of stress in children raised in lesbian households during early childhood, the result of dealing with teasing, social stigmas, and the unique difficulties of living as a minority. But by the age of 17, the levels of stress even out, probably because of the problem solving, communication, and other skills most of these mothers employ in their homes to help their children adjust, respond, and thrive in a majority culture.
So, if children raised in lesbian households are doing well, and by some measures are thriving compared with their majority straight-family peers, I’ve been wondering about another measure of personal wellness and development we generally ascribe to family and parenting: gender identity. Age-old assumptions that children need a parent of their biological gender present in the family in order to complete their own emotional and sexual development may, in fact, be unfounded. In other words, Billy may not need a Dad to understand his maleness. Andrea may not need a Mom to understand her femaleness.
Just as this new research is beginning to teach us about the key qualities that parents of any gender can use to raise healthy, resilient, successful children, similar research is needed to tease out the key factors that enable children to live into their own sense of gender identity. After all, families of one parent have been raising a large number of children in our culture and around the world for millennia. And while very few of the children of these single parent families identify as having personal struggle with their own gender identity, many sociologists, historians and psychologists argue that being raised in a single parent home, most often the mother, leaves boys without the modeling of adult men as fathers who can love children, their partners, and lead happy, connected, and responsible lives.
Whatever we learn about gay and lesbian families from this emerging research, you can be sure that it will help us all to expand our experience of family, marriage, and parenting roles. And no matter how we configure our own families, we all need help and inspiration to be the best parents we know how to be. Our children depend on it.
© Copyright 2010 by Lynne Silva-Breen, MDiv, MA, LMFT, therapist in Burnsville, Minnesota. All Rights Reserved.
Permission to publish granted to GoodTherapy.org. The preceding article was solely written by the author named above. The view and opinions expressed are not necessarily shared by GoodTherapy.org. Questions or concerns about the preceding article can be directed to the author or posted as a comment below.
bennyJune 18th, 2010 at 12:44 PM
I strongly believe that it is only the quality of upbringing and nothing else that matters when it comes to a child’s good upbringing…why,aren’t there any kids in families where a parent has left home?is that situation better or one wherein there are two mothers/fathers?!
Eric SJune 18th, 2010 at 2:38 PM
I know that there are those out there who are completely against the homosexual lifestyle but I have to say that if there are two loving parents in the home then what difference does it make what their genders are? Sure it may not be what others think of as conventional or traditional but if it is what is the best for the kids what difference does it make? There are two people or more who love and care for the kids and that is what the important things in life are all about, not having that standard lifestyle that everyone is accustomed to.
nateJune 19th, 2010 at 1:53 AM
^^ I second that,Eric…it all comes down to whether the quality of parenting is good and whether the parents are actually teaching their children about life in general…giving them morals and values,imbibing a sense of goodness in them.
ElleJune 19th, 2010 at 10:40 AM
We can all learn something positive from families who are functional and loving no matter whether they are gay or straight.
mikeJune 20th, 2010 at 8:51 AM
I’m sorry if I offend anyone here but I am still from the school of thought that kids need to be raised by a mom and a dad. They need those two role models and examples in their lives. I know that times are changing but this model of the family is not one that should be taken lightly or thrown out the window. It’s the way it needs to stay.
MelindaJune 21st, 2010 at 4:35 AM
Ok I am going to go out on a limb here and say that this has nothing at all to do with what sex your family is that you live with. What it has to do with is whether the home in which you are raised is full of love and consistency. That is what is going to make a healthy kid, not whether or not the parents are straight, bi, or gay. Who cares what the parents do in the bedroom if they are taking care of their kids in a responsible manner and giving them everything that they need to become contributing and productive members of society? It baffles me that we still have to have these kinds of conversation today, that there are still enough people who remian so close minded about it that we still have to bring up the issue from time to time. Get over it people! If gay families are doing a better job at raising their kids then take a look at what they are doing and try to add a little of that to your own parenting skills.
June 21st, 2010 at
Thanks for each and every comment – I’m glad to have stimulated your thinking and reflection.
Mike, thanks for connecting directly with the point I was making in this post. Can you say some more about Why you believe that two parents of different genders are needed to have children understand their own gender?
Recent research may prove that gender identity is more about the way the brain functions and less about modeling. Do you think that could be true? why or why not?
Leave a Comment
By commenting you acknowledge acceptance of GoodTherapy.org's Terms and Conditions of Use.
Search Our Blog
- Jeff: My only fear about using sitcoms as a reference point about different cultures would be that if people find then funny, then they could...
- Angie R: I wouldn’t think that I would actually want to keep working with someone that I felt like abandoned me in my time of need. I am sure...
- Deb: I wonder why for some people this holds them back tremendously and then for others it is actually a motivational type of thing?
- Levi: If you start enforcing these things early then you have a much easier time keeping them enforced than you do if you start trying to do it as...
- Ronnie: This really could help due to the breathing exercises that could go along with the practice, I do not doubt this,